Latest Reviews
An often subtle but absolutely brilliant collaborative effort. This edit shows a lot of love for the material and great care, thought and effort is displayed throughout. This is TROS...
TMBTM has crafted a genuinely unique and fascinating take on the original Star Wars. Using footage from various sources to reinsert alternate takes, deleted scenes and new music, the story...
David Lynch's 'Dune' has always been one of my favourite movies. I unreservedly love the theatrical cut but spicediver's 'Alternative Edition Redux' was a wonderful experience too but it's...
While I was interested in the Babylon 5 series, its sheer length intimidated me. I had also heard from fans of the show that a fair amount of the...
This review is for both parts of this edit. I admit I’d given up hope on the Hobbit. I’m someone who first was exposed to...
This review is for both parts of this edit. I admit I’d given up hope on the Hobbit. I’m someone who first was exposed to...
Alright, first off, HOW did they not go with that alternate ending?! I know, Marvel movie, crowd pleaser, but this is just such a revelation for movies like this that...
I gotta hand it not only to HAL but all the talented members of OriginalTrilogy.com, they managed to make Rise of Skywalker satisfying! All of the little details: ...
Licence To Kill is a pretty good and somewhat underrated Bond film. It has moments of bad acting and misguided jokes, but the basic structure is sound, Dalton is good...
I have said it before and I will say it again. This along with "War of the Stars", is the reason I love watching fanedits. And even though there are...
Man o man this is fun. I was watching this and thinking what if I was able to watch this while sitting in my 69 Malibu at a drive...
What TMBTM has done with this edit, editing The Empire Strikes Back and Return of the Jedi into a single 2 hour 15 minute film with a completely coherent narrative...
Brilliant.
As someone who hasn't watched 3 or 4, I came in with no bias. I thought that the fact ADigitalMan edited 2 movies together it would be noticeable....
I really enjoyed this edit. It's much faster than the cinema cut and cuts out a lot of nonsense. Granted, there were a few obvious edits (e.g the buzzsaw, the...
Wow. I hope this doesn't sound pessimistic, but I didn't expect to like this so much. I actually liked Joker a lot, and didn't really believe a 45min edit could...
All of Kerr's LotR edits (so far, just finished Book IV) have been excellent, but this one has to be the ballsiest. Flawlessly cutting out all of the non-book segments...
This is about as good as this movie can get without drastically altering the story. There's a few things that I personally may have removed and/or kept, but overall this...
This was my first Bobson Dugnutt fan edit I've watched and I'm glad it was Thor-The Dark World, which I think is an underrated member of the Marvel lineup. As...
Another excellent LS entry in the 007 franchise. A modest edit which trims / replaces the most egregious bits. It was an interesting experience to watch this while I'm finishing...
Ghost in Shell 2017... More like Blade Runner 2049 on steroids. The movie is not that bad actually. Obviously, it is miles away from the original anime movie. ...
There didn't seem to be too many cuts or changes from what I remember, but the movie is so much more enjoyable. Cut the dumb jokes, but it is still...
What worked: KK3's new format and restructuring is a great improvement, as it was able to keep Silver's intentions and Kreese's fate ambiguous while also salvaging their master plan scenes....
Wakeupkeo says they make bad movies less bad, and that statement couldn't be truer about Suicide Squad. The theatrical version of Suicide Squad is a disaster, filled with bad jokes...
My favorite episodes are the original two. The upgrading of the colors and such with a good tv........ah bliss. But gee let me watch yet another SW edit..lol. Now just...
There is not much i can add that other reviewers have not already stated. So in the vein of the edit its self here is a review with...
I quite like The World is Not Enough to begin with, it's probably my favourite of the Brosnan Bonds, but it's certainly far from perfect. It's a film with a...
Lovecraft Actually is a very fun way to watch In the Mouth of Madness, Deep Rising and The Mist all at the same time, whilst also breathing new life and...
As always, Hal brings the best. Not his most ambitious cut, but it still manages to improve upon the original and actually create a fun watch. I still had...
As usual, Bobson Dugnutt has done a great job! The inclusion of such scenes like Frigga's alternate death scene, and Jane exploring Asgard gave it more story, and I feel...
I enjoyed the 'Rise of Skywalker' ride at the cinema but on re-viewings the flaws inevitably become all too clear. I don't even blame J. J. Abrams, he had...
A new Bond fanedit is always of interest to me. It's little secret in this fanediting parts just how much of a Bond fan I am, so I was...
Nothing much really needs to be said about this edit other than it's another fantastic interwoven narrative from the mind of JobWillins. I'm convinced this man/woman is the brainchild of...
As a massive fan of the original and iconic series starter Alien, and the less thrilling but still enjoyable Prometheus, I was very excited to see how JobWillins could interweave...
Groucho Marxist gets straight to the point of Joker and is arguably a more impactful film in the end. The inclusion of The Firing Line interview at the beginning of...
I'm one of the three people who loved Jupiter Ascending, so I don't think it *needed* a fan edit, but The House of Abrasax is an excellent alternate version and...
See my full review of the overall fanedit over on Part 1 - https://ifdb.fanedit.org/twin-peaks-between-two-worlds-part-i/
See my full review of the overall fanedit over on Part 1 - https://ifdb.fanedit.org/twin-peaks-between-two-worlds-part-i/
See my full review of the overall fanedit over on Part 1 - https://ifdb.fanedit.org/twin-peaks-between-two-worlds-part-i/
See my full review of the overall fanedit over on Part 1 - https://ifdb.fanedit.org/twin-peaks-between-two-worlds-part-i/
Q2's streamlined take on Twin Peaks: The Return is fun. Cooper's journey back into the town that needs him the most is now 4 hours faster (252 minutes to be...
This edit finds the perfect balance between the Despecialized edit and Adywan's Revisited. While I also enjoy those edits, Hal's edits of the OT feel like what Lucas should have...
Mr White takes an already amazing show and strips back subplots in favour of a more focused Walt/Jesse narrative. It'sOnRandom has perfectly edited the series down to just under 2hours,...
Probably the best edit in terms of "improvement over source material" I've ever seen, TM2YC makes MOS a truly enjoyable movie. 10/10.
As someone who has always liked Superman III and Superman IV, I had to write about how much I enjoyed this fanedit. The way this edit was able to weld...
We'll have fun fun til the monster takes you away. Three completely different movies yet the same. Great storytelling. Downloaded watched and ignored the things I needed to do until...
This is a great edit over all. It tightened up the pacing and made for an more enjoyable experience. Most of the extraneous material has been trimmed away, although it...
I found the theatrical version of The Battle of the Five Armies extremely tedious to the point of being nigh unwatchable, so I was really interested in seeing what Kerr...
How it should have ended. Seriously, the best part of this fan edit is the absolutely brilliant decision to cut the laborious "dwarven gold" setpiece...
While many editors try to turn the Hobbit trilogy into one or two movies, this edit makes the case that these movies can shine individually. Indeed, by trimming some of...