Latest Reviews

Ladies and gentlemen, it's finally here: the edit that transforms AOTC into a GOOD Star Wars movie. Yes, you read that right. Octoroxx's edits are so seamless, the alteration of...

L8wrtr's editing is the *cleanest* (least noticeable) of any ROTS I've seen, but in the end, I think the edit is not quite as good overall as the original cut...

I think that we all agree that the original movie is really bad, the character isn't brought to life like it should and the most sad thing is they didn't...

Let me start by saying that I am a huge comic book movie fan, and an even bigger Batman and Superman fan. However, after seeing BvS in theaters I was...

The Marvel Cinematic universe has a formula that works for a lot of people, among those me, for the Original Thor Dark World movie they hired a visionary director who...

Reese did what he set out to do, cut the fat from a movie bloated with subplots by whittling it down to to the title match it should have been....

When I left the theater after seeing the first of the Hobbit "trilogy," I didn't enjoy the movie on the whole, but appreciated elements of it. My end game was...

Bravo reeseevans, Bravo! If you watch this cut, I think you will be pleasantly surprised to find this was probably how the original script was...

Njvc has taken an ambitious project and tried to fix some of the issues Dark Knight Rises had. I think many agree this movie was trying to tackle too...

The Iron Man character in the Marvel Universe has had 2 misfires, the first being the second movie and the third one being the second. It is true that the...

As a Bond fan the original movie was a sad moment in my life, form Madonna to surfing icebergs and the invisible car, everything was a mess, for goodness sake...

As a Bond fan the original movie was a sad moment in my life, form Madonna to surfing icebergs and the invisible car, everything was a mess, for goodness sake...

I have to confess that I am a fan of Daniel Craig as Bond, I believe in his portrayal of the character. I liked Skyfall a lot and had huge...

The first hour and a half or so of this edit is phenomenal and truly amazing, if it stayed that good it would almost have a 10/10 score for me...

I've never been a big fan of the Hunger Games, I enjoy the second movie and a great part of the first, the books were nice but they did not...

This is'nt a bad one really, Zion is'nt really missed, the scenes on the ships are our best window into the ''real world'' and don't deter the drama all that...

This film is terrible. But this edit actually makes it watchable. This fanedit is of extremely high quality and demonstrates a thorough understanding of storytelling, pacing and character, much moreso...

As the ratings to the right of this review spell out, I really can't simply comment on the work as a whole, rather I need to break it down into...

Josh Trank's disastrous movie repurposed as a television pilot is an idea that sort of demands you pay attention to it against your better judgements...but the key to fanediting is...

I just finished watching this. Wow, did reeseevans cut the crap out of this. And by that I mean all of the garbage that kept making you facepalm and let...

SPOILERS AHEAD!!! Excellent job. Took out most of the boring Perkins stuff, which was a great move since it didn't help the movie at all. Loved the...

This was my least favorite Star Wars movie (I find Anakin annoying in this one) but this edit makes it tolerable enough to watch again (and again). Gone in my...

This is a great edit! All that needs to be there (to make a decent, cohesive movie) is there. All of the fat has been trimmed. The movie no longer...

The Amazing Spider Man franchise was always something that I had a lot of hope for, it had everything in check to be great, but for whatever reason it ended...

OMG!!! This just blew my mind, it was an excellent experience watching this edit. I felt as watching the old structure of the movie with a new take, it was...

simply amazing. if this was the official version it would have reshaped the dceu

JobWillin's pitch about a movie condensing both worlds is a really interesting thing, I am a huge Superman fan and would consider any way of watching him unfold. The beginning...

The narrative from DSM2337's perspective to watch Superman in a chronological order to get a sense of how Clark develops is interesting. The progression and trims of unnecessary developments in...

This is the first edit I have seen of samspider3 and being a huge Superman fan I must say CONGRATULATIONS, this edit is awesome, I really enjoyed this. Just the...

The original Prometheus movie is an awful mess, besides being a huge disappointment for fans of the franchise expecting a real prequel to the Xenomorphs, in my opinion. Severian has...

The Dark Knight trilogy I believe is the best superhero development of character and plot of any superhero franchise in Hollywood in my opinion, taking one of its movies and...

STAR TREK INTO DARKNESS is a movie I really enjoyed when it came out, I really enjoy JJ Abrams vision in this world, I consider the original movie to be...

I have always felt divisive of the original Hobbit movies, I love the way Peter Jackson captures the Tolkien world but his Hobbit trilogy was a let down at points,...

This is my first review for a fan edit so I'm going to try and dwell only on the editing itself, rather than any inherent problems with the source film....

This is a bold undertaking, and the true magic of fanediting... taking the narrative as it exists and flipping it on it's lid. It astonishes me that the Warchowskis accidently...

Batman v Superman is a complex, overly angry and edgy beast, but much like DC's recent ''Rebirth'' iniative in the comic books, sometimes hope is all you need to tame...

Really a phenomenal edit, the type that you wouldn't even notice had you not seen the movie before. Transitions are professionally done both in the sound and shot selection. No...

Batman v Superman: No Justice is a fan edit worth your time. To start, this new fan edit has a better, faster pace. The trimming of scenes...

Absolutely seamless (outside of nitpicking). This should have been an extra on the Blu-ray release. I've read The Killing Joke years ago and watched The Killing Joke last year. I'd...

This a fantastic edit based on a terrific idea to reduce the convoluted and nonsensical plot of Batman v Superman. Unfortunately, so much of the problem with...

Without a doubt, the best version of this film I've seen. The tighter runtime helps the film tremendously!

What a pleasure L.A. CONFIDENTIAL is. A story of cops burdened by their corruption and their consciences, lots of moral ambiguity, and wonderful characterizations and acting. But while I admire...

Seeing a childhood favourite recut to something fresh was an exiting prospect and QuackAtomic has created a fun new version to enjoy. I had often imagined seeing the 1955 timelines...

This is the definitive T2 version for me. Period! Without the cheese it makes T2 looks like more T1 (wich is my favorite Terminator btw) Well done! ...

I don´t like Batman Begins but JMB made me like it with his fanedit! The 15 min in cuts made a lot of difference and other small stuff like Rachel´s...

Another great work of LastSurvivor! I think the cuts made to H1 and H2 to join them are great... But I don´t know, for me H20 felt out of place......

This is one of the best fanedits I ever saw and makes justice to Daredevil! It cuts a lot of bad stuff and adds the best stuff the Director´s cut...

I liked how the fanedit is presented (like a double feature program of a grindhouse theater) full of fake trailers and adds. The first movie (Eletronic Killer) is awesome but...

like the saying goes, you can't polish a turd but damn does this edit try its best. definitely a must watch.

This is my firs Fan Edit and I can only express enjoyment out of reeseevans' work, it is just amazing how different and enjoyable this movie is. I love the...