Latest Reviews

Yet another rousingly successful attempt at bringing The Hobbit closer to the tone and style of the Lord of the Rings trilogy, with excellent editing and A/V quality, smooth pacing,...

A leaner, vastly improved edit on a perfectly fine but lacking film. Much better-paced and definitely more coherent this time around, resulting in a much more satisfying experience. I enjoyed...

Darthrush has truly done god's work here. When reading the cutlist, I did expect an improvement, but just a milder one. What I ended up watching was not a mere...

Nice work. After some minutes in, there are some subtly noticeable transitions but nothing remotely jarring. AV quality is excellent and favors some gorgeous shots and...

I love the Phantom, it has some fun moments and great matinee action. This edit makes the movie works well with the old 40ies pulp series with its black and...

Dexter Season 1 was one of the highest quality pieces of television of the decade and my personal favourite season. It had less filler compared to later seasons, and so...

The Sopranos first season was pretty good to begin with. This edit picks up the pace, and is certainly a good way to start of the series. Focuses mainly on...

I never watched all of the original Prometheus, only parts, but had not heard great things about it. This edit works very well as a film and was thoroughly enjoyable....

Wow wow wow I loved this fan-edit, it removes everything to do with the justice League, it feels like man of steel 1.5. the story focuses on the conflict...

The concluding movie in Hal's revamped prequel trilogy really packs a punch. I don't think it's as polished as his episode 2 edit, but this was a damn banger of...

After having seen various edits, I believe this one to be the best. I like how well scenes with Azog have been diminished or removed. He also had...

As someone who steered clear of the theatrical cut, I decided to watch your take on the material after reading a number of positive reviews. I'm glad I did. This...

I really enjoyed this edit. The pacing was a little better and Darth Maul being removed made the ending a little more impactful in my opinion (more focused on Han...

Outstanding. I too, long ignored the Matrix sequels for their infinite bloat, so opposite to the timeless and abundant first iteration - which I still esteem as...

The is the best, most balanced edit of Attack of The Clones currently available. I think it is slightly heavy-handed with some of its cuts, but overall, it succeeds in...

New Hope Revisited was wonderful but this is superb, I feel like Adywan really hit his stride, it has amazing footage seamlessly inserted, the corrections he made are masterful, and...

This is a great edit! It fixed all the problems of Ressurection and added a lot of great stuff. I didn´t know about the deleted scenes and when another character...

Jambe Davdar's documentaries are a real pleasure to watch. A lot of care and effort went into this one like the others. I really appreciate how much of the material...

I liked, although I think the runtime is very short. More scenes unrelated with Jean could be added. But It´s a cool edit and it seems Like an animated series...

I first watched this when it came out and was blown away by the amount of effort that went into producing it. Definitely one of the best Star Wars documentaries...

I think this is the version of The Hobbit I was looking for. I was stunned when I initially learned that what should have been a single film of a...

It´s a good edit and I particulary liked the end credits with a new song and a montage of all Nightmare movies! The changes really improved the movie! ...

I love the Rocketman we got, but I love this one just as much. Wonderful job at telling a more, as you put it, "complete" version of the life and...

Great editing work, but like the others said, the second part really drags everything else down. The first part is probably the best watch you'll ever have of the...

The MCU has been apart of my life about as much as something like say Star Wars. My first love for Marvel movies came from the Raimi Spidey trilogy and...

Delightful! Quite the undertaking, but macmilln does a great job of merging the two movies into one. The editing is flawless, video as well as audio.Though, perhaps it was my...

This was a great edit and loved every minute of it. The edit seamlessly melds both Avengers movies together and you never feel like much was missed from the original...

Very good edit/cut of these movies. i can recommend it to everyone... watch it, really. brilliant job. thank you.

Simple EE. Great editing. The to-do-list scene is a nice addition.

The biggest addition to this edit is the inclusion of "Peter's To-Do List". And in seeing this included, I'm of the opinion that it's absolutely essential to the story. The...

Excellent edit. Radically improves the pacing to what should have been a classic. Well done.

On paper, this is a decidedly odd but still really neat idea for an X-Men fanedit. In execution, it's quite a bit of fun. The footage from Deadpool 2 is...

After watching Hal's edit of Episode 1, I was bracing myself for a repeat of my opinion on his last edit; a nice tightening-up that couldn't save a flawed movie....

This is a stellar edit. Not enough to save the movie, but it's the best it can be without radically changing huge swaths of material. The phantom menace is...

I finally got around to watching this side-by-side with the original version. Without direct comparison, I wasn't able to tell what was edited. @"dkerin" 's editing is just that good!...

I would only recommend this movie to those who only grew up with the Joel Schumacher Batman movies or is a fan of Alfred as this movie fanedited...

I will start off by saying I did not see Spiderman Far From Home in cinemas or home video so whilst watching this edit I really had no idea where...

This is a great Fan Edit. I have always disliked the unicorn scene, not just because Deckard being replicant contradicts most of the rest of the film but also...

Brilliant job!!! I am a big fan of MCU and particularly of the solo Avengers movies. This edit brings definitely the best of the two worlds. All cuts and added...

I enjoyed this a lot. I haven't actually seen the original but opted to watch this instead of the copy in my collection. This felt good and went down easy....

Ever since the Last Jedi came out I wanted a fanedit for it. I found this to my liking though now that TROS is out it doesn't fit with the...

This is a great edit of the film I particularly like the pacing improvements and moving the final scene earlier in the movie so that it doesn't undermine Ellie's voyage...

I'm going to differ from the other reviews here by not making any sex puns and just giving it to you straight. Hmmm... Well, look, this was only...

In my personal quest to find out the right fanedits to fully enjoyed the whole (most of it) MCU I happily encounter Thor - Dark World: Hard Forged Edition and...

I was really excited for this edit because the almost identical one I made over a decade ago would be great with an HD upgrade. I was glad to see...

This is a solid alternative to a significantly dated and flawed movie. Terminators act like their function dictates they should, cornier jokes and callbacks are omitted. It's not a movie...

Coming into this film after my favorite in the series, The Order of the Phoenix, I was massively disappointed when I first watched it in the cinema. Re-watching after...

Coming into this film after my favorite in the series, The Order of the Phoenix, I was massively disappointed when I first watched it in the cinema. Re-watching after...

Fantastic job! I definitely recommend that everyone should see this version of the film(s).

A/V quality was passable, but significantly lower than the source material for reasons unknown. Editing was decent, but, as gddgb mentions, some of the choices as to...