Latest Reviews

The good: Technically flawless editing and nice trimming of some of Snyder's misplaced angst. The nits: Although the idea of fleshing out the action on the oil...

I have fond memories of first watching this film with my dad when it played as a late-night creature feature on TV in the 1970s. I've seen it several times...

My experience with the theatrical cut of GotG:V2 was excruciating. There were so many "wrong" moments, unbearably awkward, or just out of character. I remember especially disliking Drax because his...

Flash Gordon is easily one of my favourite all time pulp-esque heroes. Raymond's comic strip is filled with action packed drama and glorious illustrations. The Buster Crabb...

An edit of this movie will always be controversial because of the source, everybody seems to believe this is a flawed movie that has no way of getting fixed but...

I enjoyed a lot this edit, as I always do with the samspider3 edits, in fact, this is one I was waiting for a long time. The parts I really...

One more time he's done it! Zarius has once again created a seamless combination of episodes to create the perfect opening for the eleventh doctor, as seamless as when he...

Let me preface this by saying I'm a HUGE fan of BvS:DoJ the Ultimate Edition. The movie still has its problems, but this version fixes the vast majority of...

A great fanedit of a great serial, it manages to preserve the energy of the original while dispensing with least necessary elements that only slowed down the pace of the...

I would say this is one of the most ambitious edits I've seen, and it was mostly done pretty well. AV quality was solid, a good...

Awesome Watch! Reese has done a masterful job in making this a Leaner Meaner cut.It shifts the focus back to the title of the film.I enjoyed the film all...

To begin with, I want to say that I am impressed that RollWave was able to produce such a grandiose project that removes the major character from a story. I...

TM2YC has done an amazing job of editing a film in a way that makes you wonder how the original version was 13 minutes longer. Seriously, Blade Runner 2049 was...

A seamless light edit that thankfully removed some of the unnecessary cringe moments in the film. The colour correction really improves the viewing experience over the original too. Though 'I...

This is a far better edit over the theatrical release. All the visual and audio edits are seamless and I didn't notice anything out of place or missing. The CGI...

I haven't seen GOTG Vol. 2 since the cinema, so since its been almost a year between viewings, I had forgotten most of the jokes. This edit seemlessly removes most...

Fantastic edit!! Would recommend this to any one who loves GoT and fantasy films in general! I love the tv show and watched through every season more than 3 times...

Having watched only your Harry Potter edits, I am familiar with your brilliant audio work. This heavily translated to this edit as well, as the audio work here is amazing....

(MINOR GOT SEASON 1 SPOILERS AHEAD!) When Andreas announced he was working on a Game of Thrones edit, I got pretty pumped. Of all the seasons, the first one...

I watched the non-purist cut of this (blu-ray) which contained elements from both versions of the film, and I honestly couldn't discern which shots didn't belong to the original. The...

I heard recently that Ridley Scott wasn't happy with Blade Runner 2049, apparently the pace was too slow and the film over long. Well Mr Scott I think you...

"Great Scott! I remember this! This is how people used to watch TV. There would be a cliffhanger and you'd wait a week to find out what happened. And...

I admittedly have a bad habit when it comes to fanedits: I love watching them but I feel little motivation in reviewing them due to my tendency to get...

When I found this in one of the new releases posts I was very intrigued. A Harry Potter movie without Harry Potter. Now that must be a lot of work...

If u have the time and the source your in for a hell of a treat this edit is a lot faster pacing there is a few abrupt cuts but...

I watched a preview version of this awhile back which I know needed 1 or 2 small alterations so scores are based on the assumption these were fixed. ...

Finally we have the DoS - Arkenstone Edition =) I only have a few comments to make: -Regarding the Necromancer's revelation as being Sauron,...

Well, here it is… Back to the future – THE SERIES; The Hill Valley Chronicles; The epic time-peregrination of Marty McFly; The Scott-tastic, nonsensical, illogical fantasy-science of Doc Brown, serialised...

Initially looking at the cutlist for this, my thoughts were positive, but seeing alot of it in practice, I don't think it works. One reviewer commented saying that...

Finally got around to seeing this, and what a treat! Much darker indeed but also much more enjoyable than the original. And the audio is flawless... like how?!?!

Readers of a certain vintage will remember the "Pop-Up Videos" of the late 1990s. They were regular music videos with various facts about the songs and artists that popped up...

Before I get into this, I'll give some context. I don't really like Blade Runner that much. I think it's good, but not great. I appreciate it, but I believe...

Firstly I will just preface this review by saying my wife rather than I is the big Harry Potter fan and she enjoyed this edit. My review comes more...

Very good fan edit. It's improving all the story of TFA by eliminating the Death Star plot. And, surprisingly, it's working. But it has its weak points (who can be...

Hello there. I finally had the chance to watch this fanedit again. I had originally watched the first version of this fanedit, I and have been able...

Here's an example of an already-great film given a total new dimension with the addition of the deleted scenes. Usually such a move as this is hit or miss -...

A vast improvement over the original, this edit transforms Man of Steel into a more complete and fulfilling Superman experience. Subtle changes improve the character of Clark/Superman and re-arranging...

Sinbad brings the style and pacing of 24 to the Die Hard franchise. Some skifull editing ensures we see this blockbuster action set-piece tackled from various different angles, with the...

I initially saw this during the Christmas period, a short while before the edit was "officially" released. It was great fun to watch it then during "prime" season, but although...

Just watched the minimal narration version of this, another fine edit from the scribbler! Cracking pace, no narrative issues, set pieces were trimmed and pruned beautifully (video and audio) ,could...

Nothing to much to add, it is good. If there is a slight glitch in one of the frames i didn't catch it, so for me all is good =)....

I had the crazy idea to watch the Hobbit again. The 10-hour trilogy movies are completely un-re-watchable to me, so I searched for a fanedit. I tried watching the Maple...

This is the version that stays in my library now. The edits are seamless, and everything adds to the movie. Outstanding extended edition, thank you!!...

I am a huge Zack Snyder fanboy, and I love most of his films, Watchmen (Director's Cut) and BvS (Ultimate Edition) being my favorites. I liked Man of Steel, but...

Delaying the Phantasm's identity reveal and changing the tone of the ending are definite improvements. I'm not sure about splitting it into episodes as I am used to watching...

Having never read Shakespeare before, and since Kerr found inspiration in the play, I decided to tackle The Tragedy of Julius Caesar before I watched the edit. With the material...

Like many when Batman V Superman came out a few years ago I eagerly awaited the release of the first big screen outing of two of DC's biggest heroes that...

After countless edits of the Hobbit and a spiritual sequel to the first Arkenstone Edition made by me, the long awaited sequel to An Unexpected Journey: Arkenstone Edition is finally...

I watched this over the course of two weeks and wrote a short review for each episode in the forum thread. To summarize: This was pretty darn...

An excellent first edit that does a terrific job of modernising a good but rather dated TV Stephen King adaptation. It's not really possible to fix some of the wooden...