Latest Reviews

A really interesting and ambitious edit of the classic Superman Donner films into a more streamlined epic. Really liked the subtle changes and the unification of a lot of storylines...

This edit nixes the film's universal point of criticism. If you don't already own the film, this edit easily makes the purchase worth it. DonKamillo has turned Matt...

I already loved the theatrical edition of The Batman, but I did immediately realize it was going to be struck with "Dark Knight Syndrome", where a superhero movie I really...

The short of it: This replaces the theatrical version. Go, watch and enjoy! Technically excellent. Coherent narrative. Clear character development. There...

I have to say that I haven't watch season 5 in 20 years, and I have definitely forgotten the events to the point that this was almost like watching it...

I watched this a couple of months ago and apparently forgot to review it. It was fantastic. Largely seen by most people as the true end of the series, this...

I'm not going to nit-pick over miniscule 'how-much-under-10' my ratings are - this work is a straight 10, no quibbles! I'll fess up and say...

Tight. Taunt. Tense. In other words, better than the original theatrical version. Spence displays his master editing craftsmanship...

It's not usual, but yes, sometimes two wrongs DO make a right. It's no secret that I'm no Zack Snyder fan: his visual style doesn't click with me, and in...

So I have a unique perspective when it comes to watching this edit. My grandpa gave me his extended copies of LOTR and The Hobbit to watch for the first...

There were very few things I didn't like about the Batman, and the biggest thing was the length. Watching in smaller chunks was so much more enjoyable. This movie works...

First time seeing this edit in any form, thank you Possessed for making it available in such great quality! As I understand the original was...

Straight out of the gate, I want to say that this will replace my store-bought version as the go-to copy of OUaTiH. The additional scenes add depth, character, immersion, and...

I liked the original but wouldn't watch it again, so when I saw this and their goal, I thought I'd give it another chance. I don't know if its the...

I was hoping to get to this one sooner, but Covid blew me over! It had been a few years since I saw Super 8, which makes it both a...

More fun than the original. This seemed to be more in the spirit of the character that the original trailer promised.

I had the good fortune of being invited to preview this edit, and so saw the many thoughtful changes along the way to this final version. What we get here...

As others have already said - this is probably the best way to watch Hobbit movies. It concentrates primarily on Bilbo and Dwarves and cuts out most of the other...

This is my second venture through Bionic Bob's Star Trek edits (V being the previous one). I watched the intro explaining the changes beforehand, and I'm pretty much in agreement...

This review is gonna be harsh, but I'm not going to blame the editor for this. Okay, I'll blame him for the ending, as it somehow managed to accomplish the...

Great edit! This is my definitive way too watch this film, and I highly recommend this edit too all!

This is a very good edit! My definitive way too watch FFH, and I highly recommend it.

This edit is great! My biggest gripe with the original film is the lack of consequences, but this edit remedies that!

While this isn't really in line with my personal tastes (I'm a Post-Crisis Boy so I always liked Snyder's interpretations, his Superman reminded me a lot of Byrne and Jurgens....

Terrific, the only version of this i would watch now. Wraith, great job.

It's hard for me to review this edit as I'm not totally sure what was edited, but I suppose that's a good thing for the edit. I didn't really notice...

This is a more balanced movie, neither too light or dark, very much in line with Bronze age sensibilties as laid out in Bob's mandates at the beginning of...

I have a strong feeling this edit is going to be divisive, as all Snyder related things seem to be. However. For me, this was the most fun I've had...

For anybody who wants to live in the world of Close Encounters for a little longer this edit is certainly worth their time. Watching any of the three official...

One or two minor audio problems, but who cares, the more Michael Mann the better.

Oliver Stone's "Alexander" has always had a rough history ever since it came to cinemas back in 2004. One of the biggest criticisms - which I agree with - is...

Say one thing for Don Kamillo, say he's a master. Se7en is one of my all-time top 5 favorite movies, and so I was rather...

Being only familiar with the original film through references and parodies, I have been intending to see it for a long while but also waiting for the coincidence of the...

Yes, I have the various cuts of Superman and Superman II. Notably the TV Cut was important to me because I saw it THOSE 2 NIGHTS it premiered ,...

Huge Miami Vice fan here who did not like the movie and have held a grudge going on 17 years (holy cow!). I haven’t watched this movie in a...

The unnerving score of Under the Skin combined with The Terminator. I thought that both the scene and score selection was spot on and fit well together, that the narrative...

Bottom line: This is the best fanedit for The Phantom Menace I've seen. I've seen Phantom Editor's and l8wrtr’s. Octoroxx's is the smoothest, least "fanedit-y" edit available for this film,...

This was an audacious undertaking, pulled off with reasonable success. I'm astounded at how well the editor has blended the three films together given how disparate they are from each...

A couple edits toward the beginning are a little jarring but I don't think it could be helped much given the narrative changes. I noticed edits much less as time...

... but a standalone "Batman" movie it is not. "Bah humbug!" As a fanedit Batman: Path to Justice is nearly impeccable. As a movie it's...

A really cool concept executed quite well. The narrative comes through well enough, though I would agree that if you're not already familiar with the...

I'll be honest, I didn't watch all of this (I know it's a short and I'm a lazy fool but I just didn't like some of the music so I...

Absolutely brilliant. Seamlessly and professionally done. I always felt The Batman should have been a mini series on HBO Max due to it's lengthy runtime and this edit perfectly demonstrates...

Ever since The Phantom Menace was released in 1999, many fan editors (including myself) have sought far and wide to create the perfect edit of Episode I. Many have fought...

This was plain old fun. At first I didn't know what to expect, but when Rambo started blasting I laughed my ass off. Excellent edit for the most part, but...

There's a lot to say about this edit. First and foremost, it was better than watching the original movie. There are also several moments of pure genius/fun. Did I enjoy...

You did something I thought was impossible - making a version of the sequel trilogy that I didn't hate. This actually felt like a true Star Wars sequel (and not...

I enjoyed this enough up until the end scene, which just didn't work for me. It felt tacked on and out of place. Overall, not really much going on but...

I enjoyed this version of the Captain Marvel movie much more than the theatrical release. The edit actually makes the Captain Marvel likeable again. Will definitely be my go to...

I absolutely loved this edit. This was perfect movie to make as a ministries series due to it 3hr length time as the movie could be comfortably broken into 4...