Reviews written by neglify

This was a really enjoyable fanedit. I mean sure, there's a lot of great character building moments that have been sacrificed, but this doesn't really need them. What remains is...

This was a damn fine fanedit. I was never really a fan of "Firefly" and it took me a while to finally watch everything. But I do love the "Serenity"...

This was an incredibly smart fanedit. I totally believe that Lois died and Superman went into a drunken rage because of it. A/V Quality - 8...

I love the original Evil Dead series, the remake not as much. I was intrigued by this idea to make one super-long Evil Dead movie, but I was skeptical as...

This was a helluvalotta fun. Evil Ed has put together a kick-ass soundtrack to make this movie bearable. My only nitpicks are a few audio transitions that weren't perfect (but...

This was a nicely put together EE of The Godfather, but not without some flaws. I wasn't bothered by the lower quality deleted scenes, however I didn't think the logo...

(NOTE: The editor has fixed the editing issues I've brought up, but I haven't watched the new version. Some of my criticisms and scores may not reflect the current version.)...

This was superb! I'm blown away by the reframing job UA did, especially with the shots where he had to extend the image and create new mattes. Wowza, if you...

This is an inspired fanedit! "In The Mouth of Madness" is a wonderful film, Carpenter's last great movie, and while this edit doesn't try to replace it, it gives it...

I don't get it. I feel like I just watched the first 2 episodes of Season 1, mildly edited (i.e. nothing much cut out) and in black-and-white. Then it just...

Overall ADigitalMan did a fine job making an Unspecial Edition, even though it's a DVD the quality holds up fine. What didn't work was the montage of characters and moments...

HOLY BALLS THIS IS AMAZING!!! WATCH THIS IMMEDIATELY. Then watch it again multiple times. Repeat until you are a god.

This may not be everybody's cup of tea, but to me I consider watching this to be time well spent. A/V Quality - 10/10 ...

I love these movies and this was a fun way to rewatch them. Thanks for the fanedit Mike.

This is how The Hobbit should have been! In terms of narrative structure, this is 100% spot-on in terms of an epic Hollywood Hobbit flick. I personally didn't shake my...

Great work, Billy Batson! I've never been too crazy for this Dracula, but this is now my definitive version.

This was a pretty enjoyable Star Wars music party. I dug almost all the tracks and I thought the film was cut down nicely. There were a handful of audio...

A great Gatos fanedit, not much I can say except I recommend watching it.

This was a very enjoyable take on F13 #5. The first time I watched this movie I hated it, mainly because of the twist ending. But on further rewatches I...

This was a fascinating mash-up of the two Psychos. There are some really great moments, such as the scene of Marion talking to the cop on the side of the...

LastSurvivor does it again with his (hopefully NOT) final 007 fanedit. Highly recommended for Bond fans!

I've only seen "The Brothers Grimm" once before, a year or so after it was released. I barely remember it and I'm pretty sure I fell asleep off-and-on throughout. This...

Recommended for fans of LOST. Critiques: A) Too long, too many flashbacks, B) Couldn't always overcome the episodic nature of television, C) Hard to follow unless you're a LOST addict....

I've always been a Potter fan, but nothing too hardcore. I saw all the films in the theater, read all the books, etc etc. I haven't watched "Sorcerer's Stone" in...

Halloween 4 & 5 are a great combination, and this version is nicely done.

I skipped Pacific Rim in the theaters, in fact this edit was my first viewing (BD sits unopened in my boxes). I can't comment on how this compares to the...

HAL9000 gives us a bit of a "best of" hybrid fanedit, in that he utilizes what he felt were the best changes made by previous faneditors (including his own set...

This was a pretty great edit. Long ago I bought Rosemary's Baby but just never got around to watching it. Simply put, I knew the ending already (due to pop...

I've watched a handful of episodes of Miami Vice, but was never a big fan. This fanedit is a pretty damn good introduction for newcomers, and I'm sure MV fans...

This is probably a tie for my favorite (along with Run Marty Run). I've watched this sucker at least a dozen times and I still laugh, even now just thinking...

I loved this one. I was amazed at how deftly Dom dealt the knife to a classic. All the plot you need to know is right at the beginning (and...

I had never seen La Jetee before jswert submitted this one. The story is trippy as hell, and it's a fascinating piece of cinema. This is a great digest version...

I want whatever drugs Rogue does.

I may be biased, but this is the absolute stand-out for me. Blueyoda had mentioned this idea a while ago and I honestly never thought he'd pull it off. But...

A bit on the slow side, but a very nice, heartfelt father-son story. Definitely made me sit and ponder about my relationship with my father. Solid work.

I really liked this one. A straight-forward condensed version of Bill & Ted 1. No surprises, no twists, no real explanation for the phonebooth, just some totally awesome time travelling....

A bit on the simple side, but there's nothing wrong with that. A great little story from a fantastic film. My roommate had never seen "Field of Dreams" (shame on...

I thought this was a riot. "[You] are therefore the greatest genius that ever lived." "Thank you very much my lord." Gets me every time.

I've watched quite a few of these shorts multiple multiple times and I'm quite happy with the overall mix of stories, genres and ways to approach a short-form fanedit. We...

This was a pretty darn good edit of LOST season 1. The plot lines are streamlined well and the editing is nicely executed. For my tastes though, I felt there...

I was a bit underwhelmed by this edit. I actually enjoyed nu Godzilla, despite agreeing with a good amount of the criticism against it. It wasn't the strongest film it...

Adabisi has become quite adept at TV-to-Movie stories, this time taking season one of The Sopranos and turning it into a lean, mean 2 hour drama. The story flows quite...

This is a pretty great fanedit. Superman The Movie is my favorite Sups flick and this makes it even better. It runs smoothly without dragging, while retaining the deliberate pace...

This was pretty damn fantastic! To me, it proves that action/adventure spectacles can still be great, even if it's "just a 90-minute movie". The story moves at a fast pace...

Another fast-paced Ranger redux! If you're a Bond fan, add this to your marathons.

This was a very impressive fanedit! I'm amazed you pulled off condensing 19 episodes into a coherent 3 hour storyline. The plot moved fast while retaining key character development. At...

A/V Quality – 8/10 Good quality 720 video. At times it looked a little stuttery, but it could have been an issue on my end. ...

An excellent end to njvc's The Dark Knight Saga fanedit trilogy! I've been hesitant to rewatch this flick since the theaters, and while it's not as great as it was...

This was a pretty damn great version of The Dark Knight. Not a lot is cut, but that's because not a lot needed to be cut. The story flows a...

An excellent fanedit! Fans of Nolan's Bat Trilogy will love this cut, much tighter and less groan-worthy. I didn't "agree" with every cut, but no major harm was done. The...