Reviews written by njvc
I was really curious to check this edit out, since Ghostbusters (2016) was among my least favourite films of the year. Happy to report that TM2YC has performed some sort...
I still enjoy the extended theatrical editions of The Hobbit trilogy, despite their many faults. That being said, the opportunity for a streamlined fanedit is clear, and L8wrtr has brought...
This is an excellent fanedit, highly recommended. INH5 has improved on the original, and created a technically flawless and highly enjoyable film.
I loved this edit. The original cut is grey and dull, bordering on unwatchable. Agent 9 has brought it back to life and truly made it feel like a Superman...
This is a wonderful edit of Superman Returns, and does almost everything I would want out of a fanfix of this movie. The restructured narrative is kind...
If you liked Hamlet 2 the first time, you'll enjoy this new edit from TM2YC. It's a very gentle edit, so much so that only a couple of scenes have...
This is a wonderful first release by a very promising new editor at fanedit.org. Ranger613 has carefully and skilfully removed many of the elements that weighed...
Another mashup editor at the top of his game. Watching this back to back with Rejected was gold. Loved this one from start to finish (although I wish the mention...
I long for the day when Blueyoda releases a feature length mashup and wins FEOTY by a record margin. His work here is genius, as per usual.
I don't really know what to say about this one, except to state the obvious that the 'acting bits' are the worst parts of a Porn Parody... The audio transitions...
Really strong, I actually enjoyed this more than the movies. The only plot issue I noticed was that baby Blade's bloody hand miraculously heals once he leaves home. But overall,...
Excellent. Slight plot issue with the Bank already having been robbed by the time spidey shows up, but otherwise a really strong alternate universe take on Spiderman.
Nice mashup, but one of the weaker efforts of the bunch. The fight scenes from Daredevil are just terrible, so it doesn't help that a lot of the edit focusses...
Excellent. Rogue-theX truly is the most talented editor I have seen when it comes to re-creating the 'classic' look, including fonts, use of lighting, music - the whole deal. It...
This is great stuff. The ability to turn Spiderman 3 into a moody abstract Lynchian nightmare takes serious talent. Well done Mr.Fry
A very strong collection of shorts, for the most part filled with creative and bold choices. A Psychogenic Fugue - This is great stuff. The ability...
Very good edit. Agreed with all of the changes, and the picture quality/technical efforts were excellent. I would consider this a replacement version for any future viewings. I still don't...
Loss of points for choosing to edit Batman and Robin and for using Comic Sans. Bonus points for including the line, “I don’t suppose they have fax machines on elephants”...
Loss of points for choosing to edit Batman and Robin and for using Comic Sans. Bonus points for including the line, “I don’t suppose they have fax machines on elephants”...
The concept is an interesting one, but this narrative didn’t quite work for me.
Well constructed, but unfortunately not as strong as Mayhem Mistletoe which utilises mostly the same footage to more interesting effect.
Extremely creative use of live action/animated footage, and a solid coherent narrative. 1 point off for some clunky transitions and fluctuating picture quality between sources and also for the implication...
A bit disappointing. Felt like a highlights reel of Gordon in Batman Begins rather than a fully formed standalone narrative. Fade to black was used a little too often and...
Tells an iconic story within the Batman universe and works as a standalone story. Let down by poor picture quality/aspect ratio issues, but other than that it worked quite well....
Very well executed, save for a couple of hard audio cuts. I wish this was a tv show! And if it was, this would be a classic episode. ...
Heavy metal opening. No. Poor quality voice over . Nope. “Assification”. No. Batman and Robin? No.
Exceptionally well done. Loved the use of colour and the short narrative felt complete and satisfying. Like another episode of Joker’s mailbag’s show really! Only a couple of hard audio...
Amazing. Incredibly original and perfectly executed.
Pretty solid collection of edits with some great highlights mixed in with some not so great moments. Depths of Darkness – 10/10 Mayhem and Mistletoe –...
What a great edit. Scrooge is one of my favourite morality tales, and this edit brings out the best aspects of the tale. The use of colour was inspired and...
This is a great little edit, nip and tucking the film back in line with Roald Dahl's original wishes. Removing the reformed witch subplot and the original ending worked...
Technically amazing, thought provoking, artistic and original. Hooray!
This is a great edit for all MASH fans, especially those who loved the 'Henry Era'. Many of the classic moments from these episodes are sewn together into a loose...
I consider Son of Jorel to be the best Superman edit that I have seen, so was not sure if Avid4D's take on a combined Superman 1 and 2 edit...
This was a really fun take on Indy 4 - Highly original, as is the way of TMBTM, and in parts, extremely effective. It's an alternate universe take on the...
This is an excellent fan-fix. From the excellent integration of the new titles, to the overall tone created by the editor, this is what a fan-edit is all about. ...
More commentaries should be translated into Greek.
This is a great fan-fix, and a big improvement over the original. Agent9's cuts are smart and well integrated, removing a lot of unnecessary filler and...
TMBTM makes them like no one else makes them. This is an epic, mind bending, meditative, spiritual, philosophical brain bender of an edit. I loved the ambition and the scope,...
This edit is a perfect example of why i love fanedits so much. Severian's take on Prometheus is the film I wished we had seen in cinemas. The film is...
This is a highly ambitious fanedit, and for the most part it works exceptionally well. The vast majority of the edits are fantastic, and create a strong sense of the...
TV to movie fanedits are extremely difficult to do well, and I'm pleased to report that I really enjoyed this edit. There are many fantastic achievements in this ambitious edit,...
Rêverie by Rogue-theX. - Excellent. 9/10 I Am Will Smith by Leeroy. - Also very good. Better than the actual film. 8/10 Carry That Weight by...
This was excellent. I'm a sucker for powerful images set against powerful music, and this short has that combo in spades. Great use of multiple sources to create an intense...
Like many reviewers, the 1989 Batman is a special one to me. It's the first superhero movie that I remember getting swept up in the marketing campaign for, and feeling...
TMBTM's edits are really quite excellent, aren't they. I rewatched Jaws the night before watching the Sharksploitation Edit, and was reminded why the original film is so...
Having completed his Noir Crime Trilogy, Neglify has since turned his attention to Horror - A genre that he is clearly in love with! First, we had Neg's take...
I watched this last night and wasn't blown away to be honest. I'm intrigued as to why the decision was made to anchor this edit in...
"The structure simply doesn't let any of the characters build an arc of growth or despair; aside from being confusing, the narrative locks us out." - from Roger Ebert's review...
Quite often footage that gets left on the cutting room floor ends up there for a good reason. Having recently seen the Avengers deleted scenes, with the exception of maybe...