Reviews written by thepotatoparadox
Pros: The story is much better paced, focusing on who killed Laura Palmer. The transitions are very well done. Cons: Some scenes aren't needed and...
A fantastic recreation of a fanedit that improved the original. Makes you wonder why Bay didn't edit the film like this.
This edit really polishes an already fantastic film into a greater one by improving the pace, especially the later farm scenes. If I had one...
I have to agree with previous reviews. It's just too confusing. Which is a shame because if told in a linear manner, this could've been great.
Masterfully edited to keep the focus on the two main characters with no jarring cuts. This is, without a doubt, the best fanedit I've seen...
There were a couple of instances where the cuts seemed jarring. The new music and sound effects were also too loud in comparison to the rest of the audio. Nevertheless,...
A good way to pass the time
Masterfully edited. Could not tell when there were cuts. This edit shows that there was a fun movie under the bloated length.
Heat how it should have been. Under two hours and no boring moments.
Greatly decreases the bloated length of the original, which accentuates the great acting and production. My only gripe is very minor, but the opening credits had "Kevin Costner" spelt as...
Seamless transitions and good audio. It's not much different than other edits of this film. Nonetheless, when it comes to edits of the Hobbit of this duration, this is the...
The bad: everything is way too dark. The original suffered with this problem too, but the editor seems to have darkened the film even more. The good: The...
Thank you for taking out the cringe dialogue from the original. I would've liked if there was a version were you combined the 4 parts into a single movie....
The edits where well made and I did not notice a difference in terms of picture and sound quality compared to the original. However, I feel that, in order for...
In terms of the fan edit, the extended scenes slow the pace of the film and don't add anything in terms of character and world-building. It felt more like filler...
This fanedit cleans up the cringe one-liners and makes this into a solid film instead of a guilty pleasure. The only thing I didn't like was that the end credit...
Out of all The Hobbit edits, this one is the best. Makes you realize what a great film is inside the trilogy.