Scott Pilgrim vs the Editor

Everything was perfect in this fanedit. The visual and audio editing is flawless. The added scenes work great. The cartoon at the beginning is not essential, but why not. It's fun. Replaces the original for me.

This truly entertained me. Others have pointed out a loss of quality with deleted scenes, but honestly I didn't notice any at all.
I actually found everything to be top notch!

Honestly, I don't really remember the original version. So I had to brush up my memories first before I could watch this version.

No wonder this fan edit was the runner up for this year "Fan Edit Of The Year". RoccondilRinon did such a good job with the visual and audio editing. You barely see any difference with the original version. The new color-graded footage blends in perfectly with existing footage.

Also, I really enjoyed the subtle SFX addition and the 8bit look and feel. I am not going to detail all the new additions here so I suggest you check the full list of changes and additions on the release sheet.

Other than that, the Scott Pilgrim and Kim Pine relationship cartoon intro is top notch and I really like how it is placed at the beginning of the movie.

To cut things short, this edit is more faithful to the comic book and more true to the characters.

It's so good it replaces the original for me. Sorry, Edgar :)