Review Detail

This edit is fantastic! It is exactly what I feel the Clone Wars needs: massive cuts. The show has a lot of great moments and storylines, but I honestly don't think it is very good when looked at as a whole. Too many bad episodes and even the good arcs can be too slow or have parts I could do without. Catferoze has attempted to address both issues here. Many episodes are completely cut and those that remain have been trimmed down to the essential aspects. I am not an expert on the show, so I can't absolutely say that nothing was cut that I would have liked to see included. But in the arcs that have been included, it feels like not much else could be left out. Personally, I would have left out some of these arcs all together, but that's just personal taste. The only thing I can ding this edit for is some of the technical aspects, where cuts were sometimes quite obvious from a visual or audio perspective, or both. This was particularly an issue for the first 12 episodes or so, but the cuts seemed to get much better after this. I don't know if catferoze started being more careful, the source material got easier to edit (due to less "wipe" cuts and things like that), or if I just started paying less attention. In any event, these issues are pretty easy to overlook considering the great effort that has been put into making this great Clone Wars edit.