Review Detail
9.7 3 10
FanFix
March 06, 2021
3565
(Updated: June 22, 2022)
Overall rating
9.0
Audio/Video Quality
10.0
Audio Editing
10.0
Visual Editing
10.0
Narrative
7.0
Enjoyment
8.0
First time seeing this edit in any form, thank you Possessed for making it available in such great quality!
As I understand the original was one of the earliest attempts (if not the earliest) to improve Attack of the Clones and as such it is certainly successful. Much of what was cringeworthy has been excised, and it feels to me like a lot of the choices had influence on some of the other 5-odd interpretations I've seen.
On balance though, I miss some of the material either taken out or not reinstated from deleted scenes and I lean towards HAL 9000's "The Approaching Storm" as my favourite. Even with that though there are things I would alter for myself, maybe it's time to join the club of Star Wars editors!
As I understand the original was one of the earliest attempts (if not the earliest) to improve Attack of the Clones and as such it is certainly successful. Much of what was cringeworthy has been excised, and it feels to me like a lot of the choices had influence on some of the other 5-odd interpretations I've seen.
On balance though, I miss some of the material either taken out or not reinstated from deleted scenes and I lean towards HAL 9000's "The Approaching Storm" as my favourite. Even with that though there are things I would alter for myself, maybe it's time to join the club of Star Wars editors!
User Review
Do you recommend this edit?
Yes
Format Watched?
Digital
P