Review by mullholland665 — July 23, 2010 @ 7:35 am
Not my fave chapter in this DVD series so far, perhaps because by necessity it is so short. But as a flow-on from Book 5 it’s great. Lots of little changes to the sequences in Mordor add up to quite a different viewing experience.
This part gets 8/10 from me. But the whole 6-part series gets 10/10. Bravo Kerr!
I have enjoyed your work on all of this saga, and I have to echo what spelledaren say’s .
What continuity errors??
Its impossible to match the original books with the metarial the guy had, but these are as close a match as possible.Very well edited and hard to believe we had not heard of Kerr before these edit’s. Well done Kerr 8/10 from me.
Review by spelledaren — February 9, 2010 @ 3:59 pm
An epic saga concluded. Respect.
This one really has to be watched straight after book V, as it doesn’t stand all that well on it’s own. The build up to Mount Doom goes by quickly, no matter how much I liked the little changes on the way there. Some things I would have done differently, and other things I hadn’t thought of doing were great. Most of the time Kerr makes really good editing choices. The opening scene! It worked so well, I was having goosebumps, at least until the orcs started talking…
I’m giving this 8/10. It does lack some for me to call it truly brilliant, but this is one damn fine edit in a row of fine edits.