Review Detail
9.4 7 10
Overall rating
9.9
Audio/Video Quality
10.0
Visual Editing
9.0
Audio Editing
10.0
Narrative
10.0
Enjoyment
10.0
Wow. This was unexpected. After reading what the goal was, I couldn't see how the film would work. ID4 has always been a guilty pleasure of mine
The Cuddlyninja took this film and shaped it into a very fun and amazingly workable shorter science fiction movie. It became a straightforward film with no silly nonsense. It just worked so well that this may become my preferred viewing version. Without spoilers it had one short shot where he needed the alien ship to hover above something, but you can see it was borrowed from another shot earlier in the film since the "ground scenery and area" doesn't match-- but who cares it still worked well
The Cuddlyninja took this film and shaped it into a very fun and amazingly workable shorter science fiction movie. It became a straightforward film with no silly nonsense. It just worked so well that this may become my preferred viewing version. Without spoilers it had one short shot where he needed the alien ship to hover above something, but you can see it was borrowed from another shot earlier in the film since the "ground scenery and area" doesn't match-- but who cares it still worked well
T