Review Detail
9.3 35 10
Enjoyment
9.0
(Spoilers)
This is in my top 3 episode I edits!
Thank you for making an unwacthable film, watchable.
As with any other edit, Q2 has taken out all of the idiotic dialog and pointless scenes.
The difference for me would be that you have taken C-3PO completely out of the picture and at the same time made R2-D2 just another R2 unit.
You handled the escaping of the blockade perfectly. I don’t think it could be done any better. Also, the editing is so good that if it weren’t because I already knew Anakin goes to space I wouldn’t have noticed that in this edit he does not even go into space. Brilliant editing!
Now, because every person is different and have different tastes, I will point out the little things that I might have done differently if I had at least half the talent Q2 has because I have none:
Jar Jar god awful “muy muy, I love you” , “squeeze me” & “I spek”
An R2 unit screams when it is blown away trying to fix the hyperdrive.
No virgin birth.
No abrupt ending (SECIORS ending I consider a bit better)
Apart from that which are MY personal preferences this edit is one the best edit that I have seen yet! Now, keep in mind this is still TPM and nobody can make miracles. The only way this movie could be salvage would be to make a Reboot!
All in all, Spectacular edit!
My top 2 TPM edits (No particular order):
Q2
SECIORS
I haven’t watched L8WRTR'S but have read good things about it.
This is in my top 3 episode I edits!
Thank you for making an unwacthable film, watchable.
As with any other edit, Q2 has taken out all of the idiotic dialog and pointless scenes.
The difference for me would be that you have taken C-3PO completely out of the picture and at the same time made R2-D2 just another R2 unit.
You handled the escaping of the blockade perfectly. I don’t think it could be done any better. Also, the editing is so good that if it weren’t because I already knew Anakin goes to space I wouldn’t have noticed that in this edit he does not even go into space. Brilliant editing!
Now, because every person is different and have different tastes, I will point out the little things that I might have done differently if I had at least half the talent Q2 has because I have none:
Jar Jar god awful “muy muy, I love you” , “squeeze me” & “I spek”
An R2 unit screams when it is blown away trying to fix the hyperdrive.
No virgin birth.
No abrupt ending (SECIORS ending I consider a bit better)
Apart from that which are MY personal preferences this edit is one the best edit that I have seen yet! Now, keep in mind this is still TPM and nobody can make miracles. The only way this movie could be salvage would be to make a Reboot!
All in all, Spectacular edit!
My top 2 TPM edits (No particular order):
Q2
SECIORS
I haven’t watched L8WRTR'S but have read good things about it.
1