Review Detail
9.3 29 10
(Updated: September 02, 2012)
Enjoyment
10.0
Can’t say much that aready been said. This is my go to version also.
Some others fanedits are great too, but this one, while removing a lot, almost has that “Star Warish” lenght and feels like a true Star Wars movie instead of just a great fanedit.
Reorganization of the scenes is here pushed to the limit of what can be done with editing without a heavy load of special effects.
I don’t know if I’m totaly sold on the new transformation of Palpatine but it’s working okay and I like all the rest of the cuts.
Also loved rewatching it with the commentary done by L8wrtr.
I watched the AVCHD version and it was great quality.
10/10
Some others fanedits are great too, but this one, while removing a lot, almost has that “Star Warish” lenght and feels like a true Star Wars movie instead of just a great fanedit.
Reorganization of the scenes is here pushed to the limit of what can be done with editing without a heavy load of special effects.
I don’t know if I’m totaly sold on the new transformation of Palpatine but it’s working okay and I like all the rest of the cuts.
Also loved rewatching it with the commentary done by L8wrtr.
I watched the AVCHD version and it was great quality.
10/10
T