Doom was an awful movie and the best thing I can say about this edit is that it’s not as awful anymore. Technically flawless, it’s a great editing job that removes the most ridiculous moments from the movie. Unfortunately, it doesn’t elevate it above your standard space monster B-movie fare. This is no fault of the editor; he did the best that could be done using the source material.
If you HAVE to watch Doom, watch this version. Otherwise there are much better movies out there, fanedited or otherwise.