Captain America: The Winter Soldier - Defrosted Edition

I have long been appreciative of the work of faneditors, and I have to marvel at the skill level that has become commonplace. This particular film is one of my very favorites from the MCU, and this particular edit will replace the BD I have been watching - compared to Bobson Dugnutt's Defrosted Edition, the theatrical cut feels like it was made-for-TV.
This website does like to look at the technical aspects a lot more than the average viewer, but I didn't notice any problems of any kind - the flow of the story was flawless, there were no sounds or images that felt out of place or jarred me from enjoying my viewing, and it felt absolutely perfect.

Not much to say on this one. This edit doesn't massively alter the original film, it simply extends the runtime.

The theatrical cut is great and the fact that these scenes were deleted doesn't hurt that version in the slightest. Added back in, these scenes do help certain parts of the movie 'feel' or 'flow' better and apart from one scene, they have all been reintegrated seamlessly. The one scene I refer to required a fair bit of fx work, and may only have been noticeable to me as I was watching on a very large screen.

Audio/Visual quality was great.

I can't say wether this will be replacing my Blu-Ray yet. I'll have to watch the theatrical again and see if it feels like anything is missing ;)

All in all a great edit! Fantastic work!

Pretty much flawless. I can't rate the A/V editing a 10 as I knew what was/wasn't apart of the original. If I wasn't as familiar with this movie as I am, I wouldn't not been able to tell what was added and when.

Strongly recommend this edit. Better than the original probably, just cause more is better when it comes to a good film like this!

Great edit, the deleted scenes are small, but give some underrated characters like Maria Hill more time to shine and more time with Natasha, which is always good in my book.
The only things that are a bit bad are some greenscreens in the added scenes look weird (nothing major tho, and very good for a fan edit with unfinished material) and the newly added last line of the movie gets cut off.
I recommend it thoroughly.

Love this extended version. It's only 3 minutes longer but manages to give some very nice (and much needed) character moments to Nick Fury, Black Widow and Maria Hill. The only issue I had is that the final line is cut off very abruptly. I know its an extended shot from a trailer, so there isn't much more to work with, but it is unfortunately a fairly jarring cut. Additionally, a few of the deleted scenes had some muddy audio. This is otherwise a fantastic extended cut and has become my definitive version for future rewatches!