Review Detail
9.4 83 10
(Updated: August 31, 2012)
Enjoyment
10.0
January 19, 2010 @ 6:07 pm
It is what it is guys. And this edit really works in so many ways in my opinion. If anything it made the cut scenes acceptable. This is a truly brilliant edit, and I want to comment on so much but at the same time, I don’t want to give any of the little surprises away.
The edit also gives us an idea of what Star Wars could have been as just a stand alone film as plot points that would have taken us to the sequels are removed in this version, and you know what, the film still works and is just as fun without it.
The Good: Honestly, I love the little things. The tracked blood effects. Wow. Nice work there. It was stuff like that gave Star Wars a good bit more grit. Maybe a little blood in the prequels perhaps, TMBTM?
The Bad: Not really bad at all, but I would have liked to see more creativity in R2′s subtitles. But like jjrdias said before…”Maybe they need gold.” =)
Well done, TMBTM.
It is what it is guys. And this edit really works in so many ways in my opinion. If anything it made the cut scenes acceptable. This is a truly brilliant edit, and I want to comment on so much but at the same time, I don’t want to give any of the little surprises away.
The edit also gives us an idea of what Star Wars could have been as just a stand alone film as plot points that would have taken us to the sequels are removed in this version, and you know what, the film still works and is just as fun without it.
The Good: Honestly, I love the little things. The tracked blood effects. Wow. Nice work there. It was stuff like that gave Star Wars a good bit more grit. Maybe a little blood in the prequels perhaps, TMBTM?
The Bad: Not really bad at all, but I would have liked to see more creativity in R2′s subtitles. But like jjrdias said before…”Maybe they need gold.” =)
Well done, TMBTM.
M