Review Detail
8.5 8 10
(Updated: September 03, 2012)
Overall rating
9.0
Audio/Video Quality
10.0
Visual Editing
8.0
Enjoyment
9.0
February 13, 2009 @ 10:21 pm
I’m surprised this edit isn’t reviewed much more highly. I agree that there are some continuity issues (magic rocks, sister being killed in an “alley”, etc.), but as a fanedit, the idea is perfect. Execution could be slightly improved, but overall, very few changes would need to be made for this to be finished.
This edit has an intensity not experienced with the original and is an obvious improvement. Mr. Shamalamadingdong can’t make a gimmick-free movie and thanks to Voodl, we have one!
entertainment 4.5/5
fanediting 4/5
video 5/5
audio 5/5
original 3/5
fanedit 4/5
4.5/5? – man i REALLY wish there was a more expansive rating system for this one!
4/5
I’m surprised this edit isn’t reviewed much more highly. I agree that there are some continuity issues (magic rocks, sister being killed in an “alley”, etc.), but as a fanedit, the idea is perfect. Execution could be slightly improved, but overall, very few changes would need to be made for this to be finished.
This edit has an intensity not experienced with the original and is an obvious improvement. Mr. Shamalamadingdong can’t make a gimmick-free movie and thanks to Voodl, we have one!
entertainment 4.5/5
fanediting 4/5
video 5/5
audio 5/5
original 3/5
fanedit 4/5
4.5/5? – man i REALLY wish there was a more expansive rating system for this one!
4/5
J