Review Detail

Carlito's way without Gail!
Does it really work?
I will have to say "yes" but the story doesn't have the same impact without her,
especially at the end of the film at the train station.

The ending in this version is really short and sudden and that's where I feel we're missing scenes.

So story wise it works but some scenes feels rushed and a few minor audio transitions could be smoother but is not a big deal.

The interrogation scene with both Charlie and Gail at the office must be a nightmare to edit and the same shots appeared for a few times either zooming in or zooming out.
It's not an easy task to get that scene smooth and I think you did a great work with it.

The edit is not in HD and there was some small render glitches so it's an 8 for me in quality.
Audio in 5.1 448kbps is fine.

As I said without the love story the ending is a little weaker and sudden than the original but the edit has a higher and better pace so it's getting a 9 in enjoyment.

Highly recommended!