Review Detail
9.1 1 10
Overall rating
9.1
Audio/Video Quality
10.0
Audio Editing
10.0
Visual Editing
10.0
Narrative
7.0
Enjoyment
7.0
This is a difficut one to review.
The technicals are all top notch in that they seek to recreate a 17min Siper 8mm domestic use home viewing print. This it does admirably.,
What one cannot escape is the odd choices made by those who originally edited this together, in the scenes chosen, and for that matter their order. That they were originally like this, I completely accept, but I have to score this according to its merits and given the sheer joy and excitement the orginal conveys, this falls somewhat short...NO FAULT OF THE EDITOR...
The editor should be applauded for this work nonetheless, and such diligence and preservations are to be wholeheartedly encouraged.
BRAVO!
The technicals are all top notch in that they seek to recreate a 17min Siper 8mm domestic use home viewing print. This it does admirably.,
What one cannot escape is the odd choices made by those who originally edited this together, in the scenes chosen, and for that matter their order. That they were originally like this, I completely accept, but I have to score this according to its merits and given the sheer joy and excitement the orginal conveys, this falls somewhat short...NO FAULT OF THE EDITOR...
The editor should be applauded for this work nonetheless, and such diligence and preservations are to be wholeheartedly encouraged.
BRAVO!
W