Review Detail
9.9 39 10
(Updated: January 03, 2024)
Overall rating
9.6
Audio/Video Quality
9.0
Audio Editing
10.0
Visual Editing
9.0
Narrative
10.0
Enjoyment
10.0
The Citizen Kane of Fanedits
It's a shame there are no 11's to score, coz this just can't fit on a scale of 1-10 compared to virtually all edits out there.
This is beyond any reasonable expectation. I still recall the 70mm version which had many differences to the wide released 35mm prints coz I saw it a dozen times in theatres. I'd love to see that again, but give a choice between that and Adywan's masterpiece, I'd keep this for sure.
It's not just the restorations of lines, foley and more that make this soooo special. It is clearly a labor of love second to none.
I won't spoil it with specifics, however, I had to look many many MANY times to pick out the model work incorporated seamlessly into this. And the hologram work, displays, extra everything and yet NONE of it jars at all (unlike the special editions).
EXCEPTIONAL:
W
It's a shame there are no 11's to score, coz this just can't fit on a scale of 1-10 compared to virtually all edits out there.
This is beyond any reasonable expectation. I still recall the 70mm version which had many differences to the wide released 35mm prints coz I saw it a dozen times in theatres. I'd love to see that again, but give a choice between that and Adywan's masterpiece, I'd keep this for sure.
It's not just the restorations of lines, foley and more that make this soooo special. It is clearly a labor of love second to none.
I won't spoil it with specifics, however, I had to look many many MANY times to pick out the model work incorporated seamlessly into this. And the hologram work, displays, extra everything and yet NONE of it jars at all (unlike the special editions).
EXCEPTIONAL:
W
W