Review Detail
9.9 39 10
Overall rating
10.0
Audio/Video Quality
10.0
Audio Editing
10.0
Visual Editing
10.0
Narrative
10.0
Enjoyment
10.0
What a labour of love. Not much to say about this edit that hasn't been said already. It's pretty much flawless. All of the changes are intergrated nearly seemlessly and really enrich the world.
I suspect the most controvesial additions will be during the AT-ATs scenes on Hoth which are probably the most obvious changes. Personnally I think they look great and perfectly fit in with Adywan's mission to proceduce what the special editions should have been. Many of the other changes are pretty subtle and I suspect someone watching for the first time would assume that they were part of the original release.
There's the odd scene which still stands out. The effects for Luke's fall in Bespin are still a bit ropey but at least we've got rid of the bizzare scream as he's falling.
Overall, this is essential for star wars fans and will be my go to version.
I suspect the most controvesial additions will be during the AT-ATs scenes on Hoth which are probably the most obvious changes. Personnally I think they look great and perfectly fit in with Adywan's mission to proceduce what the special editions should have been. Many of the other changes are pretty subtle and I suspect someone watching for the first time would assume that they were part of the original release.
There's the odd scene which still stands out. The effects for Luke's fall in Bespin are still a bit ropey but at least we've got rid of the bizzare scream as he's falling.
Overall, this is essential for star wars fans and will be my go to version.
User Review
Do you recommend this edit?
Yes
Format Watched?
Digital
N