Review Detail
9.2 8 10
Overall rating
9.4
Audio/Video Quality
9.0
Audio Editing
9.0
Visual Editing
10.0
Narrative
10.0
Enjoyment
9.0
This was a great, subtle edit of Return of the Jedi. I was thinking of revisiting my old ROTJ edit, but there's no need now, as this is far better.
Most of the changes aren't very noticeable and may take you by surprise. Overall, you can just feel that the pacing is better, that the tory is working more. It's a very clever edit and I feel it's an improvement over the original.
My only nitpick is that a few shots with some SE CGI still remain, one noticeably in Jabba's Palace. I'd personally try to remove every trace of modern CGI except possibly the planet montage at the end. For some reason, that feels like it fits.
Most of the changes aren't very noticeable and may take you by surprise. Overall, you can just feel that the pacing is better, that the tory is working more. It's a very clever edit and I feel it's an improvement over the original.
My only nitpick is that a few shots with some SE CGI still remain, one noticeably in Jabba's Palace. I'd personally try to remove every trace of modern CGI except possibly the planet montage at the end. For some reason, that feels like it fits.
S