Review Detail

This is very well done, and I enjoyed watching it, but this is the only film in HAL9000's prequel trilogy that I did not prefer compared to the original. For example, I did not like the decision to keep Padme alive because I did not understand how that fit with the original trilogy. I had to look it at the changes to see that the purpose of that was to match a line from Return of the Jedi. Still, that was simply the editor's choice, and it was executed well, so for those looking for that kind of change, it will be appreciated. Overall, Episode 3 is the best of the prequel trilogy, so I think it does not need as much editing as the other two, but I commend HAL9000 for his work on this trilogy altogether.