Review Detail
8.5 28 10
FanFix
June 30, 2012
15245
Overall rating
8.0
Audio/Video Quality
8.0
Audio Editing
8.0
Visual Editing
8.0
Narrative
8.0
Enjoyment
8.0
The one that started it all...
This edit deserves it's hallowed place in editing history, despite the fact that many episode 1 edits have arguably improved on it since. You have to remember that no fan really re-edited anything before this came out, and it was pretty big news that someone had been bold enough to stick it to The Man (...George) and put this out into the stratosphere. I love listening to the commentary when watching this thing, and hearing the perfectly reasonable and thoughtful ideas behind the edits. In fact, they're so clearly stated that one wonders if maybe even George Lucas himself would be convinced...but then, probably not.
This edit belongs in a Museum. But Shadow of the Sith is my replacement disk.
This edit deserves it's hallowed place in editing history, despite the fact that many episode 1 edits have arguably improved on it since. You have to remember that no fan really re-edited anything before this came out, and it was pretty big news that someone had been bold enough to stick it to The Man (...George) and put this out into the stratosphere. I love listening to the commentary when watching this thing, and hearing the perfectly reasonable and thoughtful ideas behind the edits. In fact, they're so clearly stated that one wonders if maybe even George Lucas himself would be convinced...but then, probably not.
This edit belongs in a Museum. But Shadow of the Sith is my replacement disk.
N