Review Detail
7.8 21 10
(Updated: September 15, 2012)
Enjoyment
8.0
Review by bionicbob — October 2, 2010 @ 5:33 pm
Utterly Clever and Charming”
This edit has been on my “I really should watch this” list for years now.
And now I totally regret that I waited so long.
This was so FUN! An absolute joy to watch! I enjoyed every second of it.
I can only imagine the hours and hours and hours that went into this finding the footage to craft this all new narrative. This really must have been a work of love and passion.
If I was to nitpick (it’s what Trekkers do, eh?), I thought the closing “planet joke” came off as a little cold, cruel and out of character, but I totally understand why it was done and it works as a good closer.
And to chirp in on the original footage vs. remastered debate, if another version were ever made, I think using Remastered Clips would only enhance the viewing experience more. But that’s only my imo.
Definitely a good time and I recommend it to anyone who has not seen it and is a Trek fan.
Utterly Clever and Charming”
This edit has been on my “I really should watch this” list for years now.
And now I totally regret that I waited so long.
This was so FUN! An absolute joy to watch! I enjoyed every second of it.
I can only imagine the hours and hours and hours that went into this finding the footage to craft this all new narrative. This really must have been a work of love and passion.
If I was to nitpick (it’s what Trekkers do, eh?), I thought the closing “planet joke” came off as a little cold, cruel and out of character, but I totally understand why it was done and it works as a good closer.
And to chirp in on the original footage vs. remastered debate, if another version were ever made, I think using Remastered Clips would only enhance the viewing experience more. But that’s only my imo.
Definitely a good time and I recommend it to anyone who has not seen it and is a Trek fan.
B