Review Detail
9.2 16 10
(Updated: September 13, 2012)
Enjoyment
9.0
Review by TMBTM — August 19, 2009 @ 11:58 pm
I did like the original movie (not a masterpiece, but an entertaining creepy movie)
but one thing I did not like much in the original is that the rejects were almost shown as cool badasses. Now they a’re more “monsters” as said tranzor.
Less family’s silly moments screentime means more focus on the Sheriff and his revenge, indeed.
So I think the main goal of the faneditor is reached.
Does that make it a better movie? Depends of the audience I suppose. To me it’s: yes.
The black and white is a must see if you want a more creepy feeling.
I just feel that one or two new transitions could have been done another way, but I talked with tranzor and understood his reasons.
So I’d give the original a 7/10
Tranzor edit: 8/10.
and the black and white tranzor edit 9/10
(+1 point just to turn the movie black and white may seems a bit too much but I really think it’s a plus for the edit.
The high contrast gives to some scenes an almost abstract feeling that I really liked)
I did like the original movie (not a masterpiece, but an entertaining creepy movie)
but one thing I did not like much in the original is that the rejects were almost shown as cool badasses. Now they a’re more “monsters” as said tranzor.
Less family’s silly moments screentime means more focus on the Sheriff and his revenge, indeed.
So I think the main goal of the faneditor is reached.
Does that make it a better movie? Depends of the audience I suppose. To me it’s: yes.
The black and white is a must see if you want a more creepy feeling.
I just feel that one or two new transitions could have been done another way, but I talked with tranzor and understood his reasons.
So I’d give the original a 7/10
Tranzor edit: 8/10.
and the black and white tranzor edit 9/10
(+1 point just to turn the movie black and white may seems a bit too much but I really think it’s a plus for the edit.
The high contrast gives to some scenes an almost abstract feeling that I really liked)
T