Review Detail

8.9 11 10
FanMix May 26, 2015 4416
(Updated: September 26, 2015)
Overall rating
 
8.8
Audio/Video Quality
 
10.0
Visual Editing
 
10.0
Audio Editing
 
7.0
Narrative
 
8.0
Enjoyment
 
9.0
Furious edit of Stone’s Killers slices away all lulls, dream sequences, and moralizing. This is a blistering grinder of Tarantino’s original script (which I have not read) that hurtles ahead like the running of the bulls in Pamplona. thecuddlyninja’s version does not resemble a Stone film, nor one of Tarantino’s knockoffs. Instead, this reminds me of full bore Takashi Miike. I mean that as high praise.

Video - 720 video stream. Outstanding mix of black n white, distortion, inappropriate zooms, hard cuts, etc ... Many, many visual tricks and changes keep this film popping. Even what could have been mistakes work well and look amazing in a down n dirty, drive-in thrasher.

Audio - 2 channel, 192K AC3. Sound was very good, though suffered occasionally when original score was wiped. Dialogue not always clear. No subs.

I had a real problem with new song selection, which Neglify touched on. I dislike Tarantino, but still, every time I heard a familiar cue, I cross checked it in my memory. Reservoir Dogs - Kill Bill - Pulp Fiction - Death Proof - Pulp Fiction again ... It was distracting and yanked me straight out of cuddly’s edit, especially when I got stuck trying to recall which QT film the cue was from.

To my mind, it takes a certain amount of balls and chutzpah to reedit a film. I find it sad when a fan-editor shrinks back from displaying their own musical taste and knowledge, and instead apes Mr QT. Come on, be original with reconstruction. New tunes! That said, all of us have viewed fanedits and studio releases marred by unfortunate song selection. The line between cool and fool is a thin line. Tarantino’s idiosyncratic musical taste is easy to decipher, however. Blaxsploitation, 70s Nikkatsu, surf guitar, literally hundreds of selections are viable. If nothing else, ask fellow members for suggestions next time.

Narrative - With so much footage sheared, coherency suffers. Example: when Mickey is in Drug Zone we figure out he needs anti-snake medicine. How and when he was bitten ought to have shown. Another mystery: how did that Botango riot start? Throughout the story, I always knew what was occurring, but I think 5 minutes of bits here and there would have clarified any confusion caused by wholesale cutting.

Enjoyment - I had to think about this. I enjoyed, still enjoy, and rewatch Natural Born Killers every couple of years. cuddlyninja has studied QT’s script (Director Tarantino I view as borderline plagiarist, by the way, with few original ideas) and given NBK the Swisha House treatment - chopped and screwed - to remarkable effect. This is a delicious, in many ways authentic, companion to the original. In another world, I could envision this being included in the DVD box as the “storyboard print.”

Recommend this? Absolutely. This is pedal down, all the way.

User Review

Do you recommend this edit?
Yes
Format Watched?
DVD
Report this review Was this review helpful? 0 0

Comments

1 results - showing 1 - 1
Ordering
Already have an account? or Create an account
September 28, 2015
Thank you for taking the time to watch and write this review. While I wholeheartedly disagree that my song selection equates to my balls, I think you make some great points otherwise. I put the Drug Zone clip as a precredits scene to show them getting arrested. It did open up some questions, though. My logic was that with the script (like the theatrical film) there is a lot of time spent pre-arrest and post. In the script, Wayne Gale's TV show shows their arrest. It's definitely not perfect the way I did it, but I felt like the arrest had to be in there. And since I cut everything with the Indian and the snake (thank goodness) there was no way to explain why he was there. I had hoped intercutting it with the credits would kinda get around that and work okay. For what it's worth musically, I just really like most QT soundtrack songs a lot. I definitely had a debate about doing original choices vs existing and for me it came down to should I, as a person who doesn't know anything about a lot of the different types of music he uses, select what he may have chosen in an alternate reality, or should I just go with the group of songs that I know, I love and pretty much everyone agrees are awesome? I get that it takes you and some others a bit out of it but I just wanted to explain my logic. Thanks again!
T
thecuddlyninja
1 results - showing 1 - 1