Review Detail
9.8 9 10
(Updated: May 24, 2021)
Overall rating
9.6
Audio/Video Quality
10.0
Audio Editing
10.0
Visual Editing
10.0
Narrative
9.0
Enjoyment
9.0
This was an awesome experiment, and I think it totally works. Technical points across the board. But, for me, its now a very different story.
And I guess that showing the blatant weirdness of the actual narrative that gets lost when you just try to keep up in the original. Certain moments that were ominous in the original, now feel almost slapstick - i.e. the chase scene with Dod. I kinda want a cheeseball score to compliment how we simply "watch a guy who is nuts keep being nuts."
I love all the minor choices that went into building the overall story, keeping the vital info needed until the end to still keep the suspense and show the parallels in interactions well.
Great work, what fanediting is all about. While I still love the original, I love this one too. Its awesome how well this works.
And I guess that showing the blatant weirdness of the actual narrative that gets lost when you just try to keep up in the original. Certain moments that were ominous in the original, now feel almost slapstick - i.e. the chase scene with Dod. I kinda want a cheeseball score to compliment how we simply "watch a guy who is nuts keep being nuts."
I love all the minor choices that went into building the overall story, keeping the vital info needed until the end to still keep the suspense and show the parallels in interactions well.
Great work, what fanediting is all about. While I still love the original, I love this one too. Its awesome how well this works.
W