Review Detail
9.7 8 10
Overall rating
9.6
Audio/Video Quality
9.0
Audio Editing
9.0
Visual Editing
10.0
Narrative
10.0
Enjoyment
10.0
I enjoyed that edit very much, Giefreg used a small percentage of Josstice, but the small touches served the edit well, and I do like Lois' speech at the end so glad the editor preserved it.
The earliest stab I did of an edit of this involved starting with Lois at Clark's memorial, so kudos for thinking alike there, it is a very good place to start, and the flashbacks only help to enhance it, giving better context to the story than just "Superman dies", now we see how important Lois was to Clark's motivation, which of course dovetails perfectly well into how she is 'the key' thematically.
The earliest stab I did of an edit of this involved starting with Lois at Clark's memorial, so kudos for thinking alike there, it is a very good place to start, and the flashbacks only help to enhance it, giving better context to the story than just "Superman dies", now we see how important Lois was to Clark's motivation, which of course dovetails perfectly well into how she is 'the key' thematically.
Z