Review Detail
9.0 24 10
(Updated: September 12, 2012)
Enjoyment
10.0
February 8, 2009
I for one really enjoyed it. Some really good work here.
I hate musicals – I hate em. So your removal of the start sequence works for me. I didn’t feel the flashback was jarring at all.
Getting rid of the camping out/Willie frantic scene – yep.
Dinner scene – well, it’s funny – but Willie is so annoying, although why she’s hungry later? I guess it works – I’d buy it.
Removal of first sacrifice – no problem, makes Willie’s sacrifice that more surprising.
To be honest – there was still too much Willie!
But – this is an improvement and having downloaded the Xvid to test, I now want the full DVD!
Well done mate – you won’t please everyone – but I’m happy.
I for one really enjoyed it. Some really good work here.
I hate musicals – I hate em. So your removal of the start sequence works for me. I didn’t feel the flashback was jarring at all.
Getting rid of the camping out/Willie frantic scene – yep.
Dinner scene – well, it’s funny – but Willie is so annoying, although why she’s hungry later? I guess it works – I’d buy it.
Removal of first sacrifice – no problem, makes Willie’s sacrifice that more surprising.
To be honest – there was still too much Willie!
But – this is an improvement and having downloaded the Xvid to test, I now want the full DVD!
Well done mate – you won’t please everyone – but I’m happy.
W