Review Detail
9.5 6 10
Overall rating
9.4
Audio/Video Quality
8.0
Audio Editing
10.0
Visual Editing
10.0
Narrative
9.0
Enjoyment
10.0
I enjoyed this a lot.
I do prefer the original red shield over the blue one from the special edition so I was glad to have that here, it does result in some image quality changes due to having to use the lower definition sources but it really wasn't too distracting here.
The Queen songs were a nice addition, I thought they might overtake the whole thing from the title but they really don't and seem to fit in pretty naturally to me.
The changes to the "Zeist" plot I thought worked better here than in the special edition, being set in the future rather than the past. The "500 Years ago...In the Future'' subtitle did make me LOL, it does fit with how audacious the segment is ;)
I think it may have lost something narratively with Katana traveling to the present so early but then not showing up again in the film for so long but that's was only a minor quibble
Overall very well done.
I do prefer the original red shield over the blue one from the special edition so I was glad to have that here, it does result in some image quality changes due to having to use the lower definition sources but it really wasn't too distracting here.
The Queen songs were a nice addition, I thought they might overtake the whole thing from the title but they really don't and seem to fit in pretty naturally to me.
The changes to the "Zeist" plot I thought worked better here than in the special edition, being set in the future rather than the past. The "500 Years ago...In the Future'' subtitle did make me LOL, it does fit with how audacious the segment is ;)
I think it may have lost something narratively with Katana traveling to the present so early but then not showing up again in the film for so long but that's was only a minor quibble
Overall very well done.
User Review
Do you recommend this edit?
Yes
Format Watched?
Digital
D