Review Detail
10.0 4 10
Overall rating
9.9
Audio/Video Quality
10.0
Audio Editing
10.0
Visual Editing
10.0
Narrative
10.0
Enjoyment
8.0
Almightycutie has done another excellent job editing this film - all cuts are very well done and seamless, and as a result the movie is much easier to watch.
I’ve docked points for Enjoyment due to some issues I have with the base film*, not from any editing work. This cut is highly recommended and preferable to watch instead of the official available versions.
*(I dislike the “Hollywood-isation” of some scenes, eg. Harry in the Quidditch match flying into the depths of a storm being pursued by Dementors before falling what looks like hundreds of meters to the ground - in the book this all took place within the boundaries of the Quidditch pitch and Harry fell about fifty feet - and the Whomping Willow scene with Harry and Hermione being flung and swung around in a manner incompatible with continued life, which never happens in the book.)
I’ve docked points for Enjoyment due to some issues I have with the base film*, not from any editing work. This cut is highly recommended and preferable to watch instead of the official available versions.
*(I dislike the “Hollywood-isation” of some scenes, eg. Harry in the Quidditch match flying into the depths of a storm being pursued by Dementors before falling what looks like hundreds of meters to the ground - in the book this all took place within the boundaries of the Quidditch pitch and Harry fell about fifty feet - and the Whomping Willow scene with Harry and Hermione being flung and swung around in a manner incompatible with continued life, which never happens in the book.)
A