Review Detail

They say the mark of a truly great film is that it still holds up with the sound off. Of course, macmilln only removed Edward Norton's narration, but the point still applies. Although this is a minor edit in terms of changes, the effect is staggering. Without the voice over, Fincher's visuals can really shine in ways I'd never noticed before and the film plays as almost avant garde. It's a fresh new take on a modern classic.

While this won't be replacing the (irreplaceable) original for me, I expect that it will enhance subsequent viewings. I'm not sure you can ask much more of a fan edit of an already great film. This is excellent work from a thoughtful, creative editor.