Review Detail
9.8 2 10
(Updated: December 23, 2023)
Overall rating
9.6
Audio/Video Quality
10.0
Audio Editing
10.0
Visual Editing
10.0
Narrative
9.0
Enjoyment
9.0
Full disclosure, I was part of the review team for this edit.
The skill on display here is obvious, especially with music selection and applications, which for a project like this that hinges so strongly on the soundtrack is extremely important. The goal here, as stated by BVC, was to make a faster-paced edit with a music video structure using the album Human After All as the soundtrack, and in that they clearly succeeded! I only wish there was more to pull from the original movie to flesh the story out just a little further.
The really impressive part here for me was the song selection, because very often it was used to expand on the narrative of a dialogue-free story. "Television Rules the Nation" is a GREAT choice for introducing them as robots, you can just feel it right away, and "Technologic" during the face-shaping sequence was extremely stressful, like a horror movie, I loved it. There are of course more but I won't list them all.
Great work! I really enjoyed it!
The skill on display here is obvious, especially with music selection and applications, which for a project like this that hinges so strongly on the soundtrack is extremely important. The goal here, as stated by BVC, was to make a faster-paced edit with a music video structure using the album Human After All as the soundtrack, and in that they clearly succeeded! I only wish there was more to pull from the original movie to flesh the story out just a little further.
The really impressive part here for me was the song selection, because very often it was used to expand on the narrative of a dialogue-free story. "Television Rules the Nation" is a GREAT choice for introducing them as robots, you can just feel it right away, and "Technologic" during the face-shaping sequence was extremely stressful, like a horror movie, I loved it. There are of course more but I won't list them all.
Great work! I really enjoyed it!
User Review
Do you recommend this edit?
Yes
Format Watched?
Digital
J