Review Detail
9.3 3 10
Overall rating
8.6
Audio/Video Quality
7.0
Audio Editing
10.0
Visual Editing
10.0
Narrative
8.0
Enjoyment
8.0
Now, this was the hard one. The bloated, extremely long, non sensical third entry in the POTC franchise.
And TM2YC makes it work somehow. Even if some scenes seem to randomly jump from one situation to the next somewhat abruptly; he is still able to deliver a coherent edit; yet it still falls quite short in comparision to Curse of the Black Pearl.
I understand that there's so much you can do with the source material. And that the whole nonsense of the Pirate King and Pirate Council can't be removed; which the overall narrative is impossible imposible to truly fix. I believe that TM2YC did the best that could be done.
As usual, a 2.0 audio track deducts points from A/V quality.
And TM2YC makes it work somehow. Even if some scenes seem to randomly jump from one situation to the next somewhat abruptly; he is still able to deliver a coherent edit; yet it still falls quite short in comparision to Curse of the Black Pearl.
I understand that there's so much you can do with the source material. And that the whole nonsense of the Pirate King and Pirate Council can't be removed; which the overall narrative is impossible imposible to truly fix. I believe that TM2YC did the best that could be done.
As usual, a 2.0 audio track deducts points from A/V quality.
H