Review Detail
9.1 3 10
(Updated: January 18, 2024)
Overall rating
9.2
Audio/Video Quality
10.0
Audio Editing
10.0
Visual Editing
10.0
Narrative
9.0
Enjoyment
7.0
This edit does what should have been done the first time it was recut by Kelly, which is keep it under 2 hours. I cannot imagine watching the Cannes cut at nearly 3 hours of extremely erratic and convoluted plot, but thanks to Chrispy I can say for the first time that I actually did enjoy this movie.
Quality and Editing are perfectly done, no issues noticed on my end at all.
Narratively, I'm shocked that you removed almost an hour of footage and there is still so much that I feel goes nowhere in this movie. HOWEVER, compared to the original this is a masterpiece and for that reason I'm giving a 9. I don't think the narrative itself is a 9 (which is why my enjoyment is low) but I think you did extremely well honing this film.
Overall I can't say I personally will watch this again but for anyone who (a) loves the original or (b) wants to watch it without losing their minds, this is the cut for you.
Quality and Editing are perfectly done, no issues noticed on my end at all.
Narratively, I'm shocked that you removed almost an hour of footage and there is still so much that I feel goes nowhere in this movie. HOWEVER, compared to the original this is a masterpiece and for that reason I'm giving a 9. I don't think the narrative itself is a 9 (which is why my enjoyment is low) but I think you did extremely well honing this film.
Overall I can't say I personally will watch this again but for anyone who (a) loves the original or (b) wants to watch it without losing their minds, this is the cut for you.
User Review
Do you recommend this edit?
Yes
Format Watched?
Digital
J