Review Detail
10.0 6 10
Overall rating
9.8
Audio/Video Quality
10.0
Audio Editing
10.0
Visual Editing
10.0
Narrative
9.0
Enjoyment
10.0
This is a shelf replacer, for sure. Expertly and flawlessly executed, it really brings the best of the series to bear.
And you can definitely notice the amount of work required for this, every transition was seamless and invisible, impressive!
In terms of the narrative, although the original has really good writing, I felt there were a few chances for improvement, here and there.
Personally, I’d be all in favor of cutting all the bits of Syril with his mother. That subplot goes nowhere and it’s just awkward. Also, Syril’s entire story and motivation work just the same without this weirdness.
The scene on Episode 4 of Andor running on snow, after getting out of prison (at 0h52m50) should be earlier in the episode. The way it’s edited, it looks like he spends days to weeks running on the same planet, to then being able to get to Ferrix in mere hours.
And you can definitely notice the amount of work required for this, every transition was seamless and invisible, impressive!
In terms of the narrative, although the original has really good writing, I felt there were a few chances for improvement, here and there.
Personally, I’d be all in favor of cutting all the bits of Syril with his mother. That subplot goes nowhere and it’s just awkward. Also, Syril’s entire story and motivation work just the same without this weirdness.
The scene on Episode 4 of Andor running on snow, after getting out of prison (at 0h52m50) should be earlier in the episode. The way it’s edited, it looks like he spends days to weeks running on the same planet, to then being able to get to Ferrix in mere hours.
User Review
Do you recommend this edit?
Yes
Format Watched?
Digital
G