Review Detail
9.3 48 10
(Updated: January 08, 2014)
Overall rating
9.0
Audio/Video Quality
9.0
Audio Editing
9.0
Visual Editing
9.0
Narrative
10.0
Enjoyment
8.0
if anyone asks what is a fanedit then this edit is the perfect place to start, TMBTM takes one the best known films and completely changes it's story. this at times caused a problem for me as i had to reminded myself a few times during the movie. the many positives have been commented here to which i can only agree with, Darth Vader is once again the star of the edit with every scene he's in
on the negative side i felt the edit ran 15 - 20 mins to long especially the opening 20 mins which for me dragged a little in places with the inclusion of the deleted scenes with the ice monster. also the cgi monster used from star trek looked out of place and would be something Lucas would include in future star wars editions. R2-D2 was a little annoying in Jar Jar Binks way and i can't recall Chewbaca having much to do during the edit. but these a small differences aside this really is one of the best fanedits of all time
on the negative side i felt the edit ran 15 - 20 mins to long especially the opening 20 mins which for me dragged a little in places with the inclusion of the deleted scenes with the ice monster. also the cgi monster used from star trek looked out of place and would be something Lucas would include in future star wars editions. R2-D2 was a little annoying in Jar Jar Binks way and i can't recall Chewbaca having much to do during the edit. but these a small differences aside this really is one of the best fanedits of all time
User Review
Format Watched?
DVD
L