Review Detail
8.6 3 10
Overall rating
9.0
Audio/Video Quality
10.0
Audio Editing
10.0
Visual Editing
10.0
Narrative
10.0
Enjoyment
5.0
This is my favorite Kill Bill edit, everything's done just right. It shows what a smashing movie it could have been if Tarantino and his producers would have decided not to cash in double...
... BUT: providing no subs for extended parts of the movie is a sacrilege, and it should have a sticker on it saying "multilingual speakers only". For an audience expecting that English language skills are sufficient this is a very frustrating experience. Of course we all own the movie, otherwise we wouldn't be watching the fanedit in the first place - but sacrificing the subs for a better cut isn't good enough.
So I'll give a "5" for enjoyment as the combination of "10" for the English parts and "0" for the parts w/o subs.
... BUT: providing no subs for extended parts of the movie is a sacrilege, and it should have a sticker on it saying "multilingual speakers only". For an audience expecting that English language skills are sufficient this is a very frustrating experience. Of course we all own the movie, otherwise we wouldn't be watching the fanedit in the first place - but sacrificing the subs for a better cut isn't good enough.
So I'll give a "5" for enjoyment as the combination of "10" for the English parts and "0" for the parts w/o subs.
User Review
Format Watched?
Digital
F