Review Detail
7.0 8 10
(Updated: September 12, 2012)
Enjoyment
8.0
Review by spelledaren — August 4, 2008 @ 1:04 pm
Overall nice editing, the movie flows on. Sometimes I felt that it was a bit rushed, but perhaps I just like that Donner tempo.
Too bad you couldn’t get rid of Lois tumbling around the airplane. With that and her getting hit by a huge metal door, but still looking totally ok and unhurt, I don’t know. But that is a problem with the movie itself, not this edit.
Good work, giving you a 4 for this, wasn’t perfectly happy, but I think you made some clever changes, and made them well. Unfortunatly I didn’t feel that movie became any better, but as you say, at least it’s faster.
Overall nice editing, the movie flows on. Sometimes I felt that it was a bit rushed, but perhaps I just like that Donner tempo.
Too bad you couldn’t get rid of Lois tumbling around the airplane. With that and her getting hit by a huge metal door, but still looking totally ok and unhurt, I don’t know. But that is a problem with the movie itself, not this edit.
Good work, giving you a 4 for this, wasn’t perfectly happy, but I think you made some clever changes, and made them well. Unfortunatly I didn’t feel that movie became any better, but as you say, at least it’s faster.
S