Star Wars - Rogue One: Where Rebels Dare

The edit starts very strong with the opening crawl followed by the pan down. What a technical wonder, I loved it. The prologue is great like this, it makes a lot more sense now.

Throughout the film, the reordering of a lot of scenes improves the narrative. Still, I’d have preferred for more scenes the be removed on the 1st act, so the pacing can improve. Also, both on the 1st and 2nd acts, it may have been possible to trim / remove some of the subplots and characters (thinking of Saw Gerrera…). As it has been said by other reviewers, I’m also fully in favor of removing the Bor Gullet scene, it brings nothing but cringe and it interrupts the flow of the narrative.

Overall, the edits were seamlessly done on both audio and video, never noticed any misplaced cut. The new / improved sound effects bring a lot of color and variety, they are a great choice.

Cheers!

Any Rogue One fan-edit that manages to give it more of a classic Star Wars-esque feel while still flawlessly showing how this is much more of a straight-up war film than the other installments in the franchise can't be that bad, can it? As much as I adore the original Rogue One, I do think this edit flows better in terms of plot and story and the altered scene order allows you to care about the characters more than in the theatrical cut. As usual with a TM2YC edit, the audio and video editing are absolutely seamless. If you're a Rogue One fan, you'll love this. If you're not a fan, I still recommend giving this a chance.

This is another strong Rogue One edition.

I personally simply like the original Rogue One THAT much so it's almost impossible to improve it for me. I don't think any of these Rogue One edits actually really improve the film (for me) but they have slightly different takes on the movie.

This one changes Rogue One quite a bit. I really liked how the Empire fleet is presented in the early stage of the movies. Great job there. Majority of the other changes were good as well but I personally didn't care how Darth Vader was presented. Something about it felt a bit odd. Maybe because it was in the middle of the battle. No big deal though. Bor Gullet should have been cut.

Very good job on this one.

I hate to give 10 stars for visual editing nowadays after the Adywan's Empire Strikes Back fanedit because it was a true masterpiece but there you go.

Really, really enjoyed this. Looks and sounds great. Highly recommend. Thanks for taking the time to make it!

*Applause* Another great cut by one of the finest editors of Fan Edits! Great addition to my Blu-ray set!

Highly recommend!