Review Detail
9.3 106 10
Overall rating
8.2
Audio/Video Quality
10.0
Audio Editing
10.0
Visual Editing
10.0
Narrative
7.0
Enjoyment
4.0
Let’s just say that to me, TLJ is the worst Star Wars movie ever and that I don’t consider it even a Star Wars movie.
With that said, this edit is better than the theatrical cut, but that was so bad it’d be hard not to.
So I’ll go with what a liked and disliked about this edit.
Good:
- Luke lived
- Casino, Finn Rose gone
- most of Holdo Poe gone
- Leia dies in space
Bad
- without the casino scenes the movie is a complete bore as it focuses on Rey/Kylo/Luke etc too much and barely anything happens at all.
Again this is Rian’s fault and not the edit.
I plan never to watch any version of this movie ever again.
With that said, this edit is better than the theatrical cut, but that was so bad it’d be hard not to.
So I’ll go with what a liked and disliked about this edit.
Good:
- Luke lived
- Casino, Finn Rose gone
- most of Holdo Poe gone
- Leia dies in space
Bad
- without the casino scenes the movie is a complete bore as it focuses on Rey/Kylo/Luke etc too much and barely anything happens at all.
Again this is Rian’s fault and not the edit.
I plan never to watch any version of this movie ever again.
User Review
Do you recommend this edit?
Yes
Format Watched?
Digital
Y