Review Detail
8.9 16 10
FanFix
June 25, 2012
4121
Overall rating
8.6
Audio/Video Quality
5.0
Audio Editing
10.0
Visual Editing
10.0
Narrative
10.0
Enjoyment
8.0
Other edits attempt to cut out Jar Jar. This went in another direction by changing him completely. Jar Jar goes from a goof ball to a sleaze ball.
The inter-Naboo politics is a nicely added layer. Ep1 gets a lot of flak for it's political themes but this actually works.
The Trade Federation is changed very well too. They are now like a Slave Trade Federation. Slaveries was already on Tatooine and its just simply expanded the idea. Nute Gunray is no longer a wimp.
This edit is much less kid friendly. Yes its subtitles, yes you'll have to read them. It works because it does not attempt to cut out parts from Ep 1 but change it and expand it.
The inter-Naboo politics is a nicely added layer. Ep1 gets a lot of flak for it's political themes but this actually works.
The Trade Federation is changed very well too. They are now like a Slave Trade Federation. Slaveries was already on Tatooine and its just simply expanded the idea. Nute Gunray is no longer a wimp.
This edit is much less kid friendly. Yes its subtitles, yes you'll have to read them. It works because it does not attempt to cut out parts from Ep 1 but change it and expand it.
User Review
Do you recommend this edit?
Yes
Format Watched?
Digital
P