Review Detail
8.8 11 10
Overall rating
8.0
Audio/Video Quality
10.0
Audio Editing
10.0
Visual Editing
10.0
Narrative
5.0
Enjoyment
5.0
First of all, given the crappy source material, this is a very well-done fan edits (all three versions are enjoyable). The BEST segment in all of the versions was the Force Awakens editing. By cutting down the talk, by significantly cutting down the Rathtar sequence, and having the final battle of TFA sequence re-edited to show real tension (and what a payoff!).
However, as best as you can edit, there is no saving the sequels. The faulty McGuffin from TLJ and the absolutely ridiculous storylines and pacing from TROS made your job very difficult. Still, it is a laudable effort, and, of course, to be completely honest, I enjoyed your edits MUCH more than the theatrical and DVD versions of all three. They were really seamless. Bravo!
[Spoilers} The Pro-TLJ sequence with the blue light saber, fleet destruction and Holdo were spot-on and the BEST version of that conclusion.
However, as best as you can edit, there is no saving the sequels. The faulty McGuffin from TLJ and the absolutely ridiculous storylines and pacing from TROS made your job very difficult. Still, it is a laudable effort, and, of course, to be completely honest, I enjoyed your edits MUCH more than the theatrical and DVD versions of all three. They were really seamless. Bravo!
[Spoilers} The Pro-TLJ sequence with the blue light saber, fleet destruction and Holdo were spot-on and the BEST version of that conclusion.
User Review
Do you recommend this edit?
Yes
Format Watched?
Digital
B