October 30, 2008
Overall thoughts: Great concept but I didn’t like the clean look of them (I’m sure I’d enjoy the Dusty versions more). Editing was great, stories were streamlined well. Only major nitpick is I didn’t like the design and font/kerning for the dialog cards.
Movie specific thoughts: Phantom Menace was still stupid and boring. Attack of the Clones was pretty damn good! ROTS was a little boring but good overall.
A/V Quality - 10
Editing - 10
Narrative - 8
Enjoyment - 7 (originals are a 4 collectively)
Recommended drink: Gordon’s Distilled Dry Gin