Review Detail
8.9 25 10
(Updated: September 15, 2012)
Enjoyment
10.0
Review by Checker222 — June 8, 2010 @ 5:26 pm
I was grinning ear to ear, an innovative and interesting cut! Cutting out and around nearly all of the problems that the motion picture had in it’s release, and adding amazing atmosphere with the replacement of sound effects, and the rehashing of the opening!
This was nearly perfect, and when I discovered that this is an early effort from BionicBob, I was all the more impressed! I’ll be keeping an eye out for everything he does in the future!
If I HAD to offer a crit, repeating what flyboy707 posted above:
At one point, Decker says "You haven't logged a single starhour in over 2 1/2 years". If Kirk has never accepted a promotion and moved on from being a the Enterprise's Captain, then why would Decker say that line?
It was the ONLY thing keeping this from being a perfect fanedit!
Congrats, and please keep it up!
I was grinning ear to ear, an innovative and interesting cut! Cutting out and around nearly all of the problems that the motion picture had in it’s release, and adding amazing atmosphere with the replacement of sound effects, and the rehashing of the opening!
This was nearly perfect, and when I discovered that this is an early effort from BionicBob, I was all the more impressed! I’ll be keeping an eye out for everything he does in the future!
If I HAD to offer a crit, repeating what flyboy707 posted above:
At one point, Decker says "You haven't logged a single starhour in over 2 1/2 years". If Kirk has never accepted a promotion and moved on from being a the Enterprise's Captain, then why would Decker say that line?
It was the ONLY thing keeping this from being a perfect fanedit!
Congrats, and please keep it up!
C