Review Detail
8.2 10 10
(Updated: September 15, 2012)
Enjoyment
8.0
Review by DwightFry78 — December 20, 2010 @ 6:33 am
I didn’t care for the reformatting, I have no problem with 4:3 when it’s the original aspect ratio. But regarding the actual edit factor, this was much, much better than the original. The removal of Wesley and Riker/Troi was very welcome. However, I think the final scene between Picard and Dr. Crusher should have been excised, as the conversation refers to events that are no longer in the story, so it feels weird and puzzling and is the one moment that makes apparent something is missing.
Overall, another fine outing by Boon! 8/10.
I didn’t care for the reformatting, I have no problem with 4:3 when it’s the original aspect ratio. But regarding the actual edit factor, this was much, much better than the original. The removal of Wesley and Riker/Troi was very welcome. However, I think the final scene between Picard and Dr. Crusher should have been excised, as the conversation refers to events that are no longer in the story, so it feels weird and puzzling and is the one moment that makes apparent something is missing.
Overall, another fine outing by Boon! 8/10.
D