Review Detail
9.8 54 10
(Updated: December 04, 2022)
Overall rating
9.4
Audio/Video Quality
10.0
Audio Editing
10.0
Visual Editing
10.0
Narrative
8.0
Enjoyment
9.0
I love this. It's near flawless. The only 'problem' I had with it is that it is too book accurate. I think the war and ending could work better if you didn't stick to the book this much.
Video/Audio editing: 10/10. Flawless audio and visual transitions.
Story: Up to the point the war starts it's a solid 10/10. Everything works flawlessly untill the war starts. The war itself and the ending is a 6.5/10 to me, though. There is just some elements missing like Bilbo being on top of the mountain with no context given as to why. Overall I give it a 8/10 for that reason.
I'd be very interested in exactly this edit with a different approach to the ending. That would be perfect imo.
Video/Audio editing: 10/10. Flawless audio and visual transitions.
Story: Up to the point the war starts it's a solid 10/10. Everything works flawlessly untill the war starts. The war itself and the ending is a 6.5/10 to me, though. There is just some elements missing like Bilbo being on top of the mountain with no context given as to why. Overall I give it a 8/10 for that reason.
I'd be very interested in exactly this edit with a different approach to the ending. That would be perfect imo.
D