Review Detail
8.6 8 10
(Updated: September 12, 2012)
Overall rating
8.0
Audio Editing
9.0
Visual Editing
9.0
Enjoyment
6.0
April 5, 2009
The edit:
First, let me note that I haven’t seen TWINE in a *very* long time, so my scene-to-scene memory is fuzzy. I noticed a slightly rough cut or two, but nothing that would detract from the viewing experience. (Also, the boat-on-land remains.)
It felt like the story had been cut a bit too much. I remember about Renard and the bullet, and hated the hologram scene, but first-time viewers would be confused. Also, I had a general feeling of a dearth of emotional depth. How much is due to the edit and how much to the original, I can’t say, but, while fun, the result didn’t satisfy me on a thematic level.
editing: 4.5 of 5,
entertainment: 3 of 5
Image quality:
I watched the .avi version and thus cannot comment, but I believe the full dvd would look faultless.
Audio quality:
Seamless except for some audio fluctuation during the boat chase… could have been an .avi issue
audio: 4.75 of 5
Overall (not an average):
It’s honestly been too long since I’ve seen TWINE to know which is better. I seem to remember one scene in particular in which Bond confronts Elektra about his suspicions, and while it may well have had its faults, I missed it.
I enjoyed the movie for most of its duration, but don’t think I’ll want to see either version again – the story just ain’t there. So, a thanks to Tubes for his effort, and
3 out of 5
The edit:
First, let me note that I haven’t seen TWINE in a *very* long time, so my scene-to-scene memory is fuzzy. I noticed a slightly rough cut or two, but nothing that would detract from the viewing experience. (Also, the boat-on-land remains.)
It felt like the story had been cut a bit too much. I remember about Renard and the bullet, and hated the hologram scene, but first-time viewers would be confused. Also, I had a general feeling of a dearth of emotional depth. How much is due to the edit and how much to the original, I can’t say, but, while fun, the result didn’t satisfy me on a thematic level.
editing: 4.5 of 5,
entertainment: 3 of 5
Image quality:
I watched the .avi version and thus cannot comment, but I believe the full dvd would look faultless.
Audio quality:
Seamless except for some audio fluctuation during the boat chase… could have been an .avi issue
audio: 4.75 of 5
Overall (not an average):
It’s honestly been too long since I’ve seen TWINE to know which is better. I seem to remember one scene in particular in which Bond confronts Elektra about his suspicions, and while it may well have had its faults, I missed it.
I enjoyed the movie for most of its duration, but don’t think I’ll want to see either version again – the story just ain’t there. So, a thanks to Tubes for his effort, and
3 out of 5
G