Review Detail

10.0 6 10
howardreplucked_front
FanFix March 18, 2021 1692
(Updated: March 29, 2021)
Overall rating
 
10.0
Audio/Video Quality
 
10.0
Visual Editing
 
10.0
Audio Editing
 
10.0
Narrative
 
10.0
Enjoyment
 
10.0
Just completed watching this and I want to really give credit to the fabulous improvement on the special effects. This is perhaps the most significant renovation on this version of the film, and it greatly enhances the overall movie.

It's always been an odd movie; I never really hated it when it came out, like many do, but I also never really loved it either. I own a copy, and every few years I watch it.

It always felt like two movies. The first half deals with Howard coming to Earth and trying to fit in. The second half deals with the Dark Overlord inhabiting Dr. Jenning (Jeffrey Jones) and the threat to the world. In many ways, the film felt overlong with too much going on after the gears switch in the middle. I fault the film for this, as the Dark Overlord makes NO appearance in the first half, so his arrival in the second is like the start of something entirely new.

Fortunately, this fanedit tightens the pace and keeps the storyline clipping along at a reasonable speed. There is no narrative change (moving pieces around to introduce the second half into the first half), but the improved pace does keep the film from feeling over-long. This makes it a better film overall.

Editing is seamless and I noticed no audio faults or issues. I don't miss anything that has been cut. So, for a film that keeps the original structure of the film but improves special effects and pacing, it succeeds 100%.

CAN THE FILM BE IMPROVED FROM HERE? That is a good question. Rather than debate "cut this scene, it's pointless," or "put this back in, I like it," I think the only discussion at this point should be, "Is there a narrative change that could improve this film?" That is a reasonable question. Perhaps dividing the movie into two parts would be one approach. Instead of one movie, we have two individual episodes (for example, Episode 1: Duck out of Water, Episode 2: A Fowl Fate). This might reinforce the comic book origin of the material while providing a reason for the drastic gear shift mid-film. This is in NO WAY a criticism of this fanedit, but the original film.

So, once again, this is a fantastic Fanedit in improving the original film in both pacing and special effects. Great Job! I loved it! If the Faneditor chooses to revisit this film in the future, you might consider the above idea.

User Review

Do you recommend this edit?
Yes
Format Watched?
Digital
Owner's reply April 04, 2021

A very thoughtful and well-put review! Thank you, kindly.
I find it fascinating that we came to the same conclusions. When originally criticizing the structure of the script,I noted how the first half has its own three act structure, almost entirely removed from a separate three act structure in the second half. I very much considered the idea of breaking it into two episodes, with a respectful fade to black after Howard and Bev are in bed together. Then the second episode would begin with them being interrupted by the scientists, bringing us into a new story.
My goal with this edit was to improve the film as a whole, and thank you for saying I succeeded, and that you enjoyed the edit. Perhaps I will revisit it at some point to tackle the structure more in-depth. Also, I adore your episode titles.
I think perhaps a future licensed Howard the Duck project would utilize a series format, and better reflect the comics.

Report this review Was this review helpful? 3 0

Comments

1 results - showing 1 - 1
Ordering
Already have an account? or Create an account
(Updated: April 05, 2021) April 05, 2021
Nice concise review and great idea with Episode 1: Duck out of Water, Episode 2: A Fowl Fate akin to Pulp Fictions on screen episodic titling.
M
muffy
1 results - showing 1 - 1