User Review
Do you recommend this edit?
Yes
Owner's reply
June 24, 2014
Hi masirimso17,
First of all, thank you very much for taking the time to review my edit. I put a lot of effort into making it and any constructive criticism I get is always received openly with the goal of improving the edit.
A few notes on your review, if I may, is that all the criticism seems to be directed to the scenes I removed--namely a majority of the Tauriel/Thranduil/Legolas scenes, and Azog/Bolg. Your main point is that I should have left all this-- but if I had, wouldn't that just leave us with the theatrical version? I have the utmost respect for all the work Peter Jackson and his team have done to bring these stories to life, and I do not presume to say that this fanedit is anywhere near as good or took as much effort to make as the theatrical cut, so I certainly respect the fact that you prefer the theatrical cut to this. However, my goal was to create a version unadulterated by some of the more excessive inventions of PJ and his team-- something that I would enjoy watching instead of the theatrical cut.
The elf/dwarf triangle-- It is completely removed in the final cut (the version you have reviewed above is the first draft workprint and is no longer available). The final cut removes all references of triangle, and has even less Tauriel. I felt having Legolas in the movie was fine as long as he had a minor role-- I did not like too many references to LOTR in the prequel, that is why I cut the Gimli line. It didn't work for me. Once the love triangle was gone, all scenes of the elves interacting with each other are irrelevant, and that is why I cut them. Azog and Bolg are undewhelming characters who are also irrelevant to Bilbo's story. The best fanedits of Unexpected Journey completely cut Azog out until the last scene (and my edit is meant to be in continuity with those).'I See Fire' is back in the final cut.
All in all, I appreciate the criticism. My vision for the movie is one free of elements which I felt did not work. This edit is supposed to stand on its own, not rely on the theatrical cut for a viewer to understand it, and I feel that it does do its job. The best action scenes in the theatrical cut (barrel and dragon showdown) are intact. I myself made a second, even MORE cut version which follows the book as close as possible with the theatrical material ("Hobbit: Into the Fire", which I'll release soon).
I'm sorry you did not enjoy this edit, but I feel less is more in the case of The Hobbit, and as far as that philosophy goes, I made both 'Fire of the Dragon' an 'Into the Fire' to be leaner, meaner cuts of the original which work for me, and some other people too I hope. Thank you for your time my friend.