Review Detail
9.2 7 10
Overall rating
6.8
Audio/Video Quality
6.0
Audio Editing
5.0
Visual Editing
7.0
Narrative
8.0
Enjoyment
8.0
I have to say I have read a lot of very positive reviews, and I feel bad giving a not so glowing one...
The good: This edit cuts the fat. *Most* of the story still made sense and made part 1 a little more snappier and action filled which I enjoyed a lot.
The bad: Sadly it was extremely obvious each time a cut was made. I know it's hard to make the sound/music seamless when you are making a fan edit, but that's the challenge, and the best editors make it unnoticeable. There was a lot of messy or obvious sound blemishes when a cut was made. Even on the visual side of things, at one point there's a very obvious lo-fi fade out tin order to make a cut.
I like what Q2 is trying to do here, but someone with more editing skills needs to do this a bit more professionally in order to make this the preferred option of viewing.
Much love, still an enjoyable edit <3
The good: This edit cuts the fat. *Most* of the story still made sense and made part 1 a little more snappier and action filled which I enjoyed a lot.
The bad: Sadly it was extremely obvious each time a cut was made. I know it's hard to make the sound/music seamless when you are making a fan edit, but that's the challenge, and the best editors make it unnoticeable. There was a lot of messy or obvious sound blemishes when a cut was made. Even on the visual side of things, at one point there's a very obvious lo-fi fade out tin order to make a cut.
I like what Q2 is trying to do here, but someone with more editing skills needs to do this a bit more professionally in order to make this the preferred option of viewing.
Much love, still an enjoyable edit <3
User Review
Do you recommend this edit?
No
Format Watched?
Digital
W